Definitely the dark brown, the lighter shade barley passes for my light brown hair. A light application will ensure a sheerer color
I have black hair and very dark brown, almost black, brows and the darkest colour MED/DEEP is perfect. I was nervous that it may be too light at first since I have tried all the high-end brands and struggle to find dark enough colours, however I find that the dark shade creates great dark depth but still looks natural. Also, the shade is AMAZING, it definitely does not pull too warm or anything so it looks very natural next to black hair.
answered 2 months, 2 weeks ago
(British Columbia, Canada)
Definitely the darker color. You'll love it!
answered 3 months, 2 weeks ago
answered 3 months, 3 weeks ago
(So. Calif., CA)
I also wanted to add that even though this looks super dark on screen, it's not that impactful out of the tube.
I'd say it's about 2 shades lighter than my hair, so there's no Groucho Marx look going on. It produces lovely results.
I hope it gives you the results you're seeking. If not, you can always exchange. Sephora has a great return policy. :-)
I have black/brown hair -- the darkest brown you can get before going black. I also have a very light complexion. I chose the darker of the two, and it works perfectly because you're applying this to the brow hairs, not the skin. I am in love with this product. After all these years of trying to color in my sparse brows that have fallen out due to hypothyroidism, I finally have a product that enhanced the light brow hair that's grown back and makes it fit with my very dark hair.
Hope you find this helpful. It's not an overpowering color.