I don't think you would like this product if you are looking for length and volume. You can layer this but it doesn't really add much to your lashes. I would only recommend to people who are looking for light coverage.

It is very buildable and you can get as much volume as you want by adding layers. However, it doesn't have the thick, clumpish look that multiple layers of mascara often has. That is very positive to me, but I have begun to believe there are girls that like the look of clumpy and "spidery" lashes.

It is more natural looking

It enhances the length but not volume of your lashes. I'm waiting for that formula :)

YES! It's SO good and makes your lashes almost look false - I only wear this at night b/c it's too much during the day! I'm a big fan of Fairy Drops, They're Real and Dior Show - and this ranks right up there w/ them.

This mascara does not give huge volume, in my opinion. It does give length and definition, in a smudge-resistant formula.

Does not make super full fake looking lashes on me ( I have long, full lashes). It does make the, look polished defined and long. If I'm going for a more dramatic lash look I use cristian Dior- Dior show. I love that the gel washes off easily and doesn't smudge. Hope this helps!

Smudge proof. I wore it snow skiing in a storm. No smudge.

absolutely not. It smeared within one hour for me , and I no longer wear contact lenses. save your money. since you are willing to shell out big bucks for mascara, I suggest Chanel's waterproof mascara. It costs $30, but it's worth every penny. Didn't budge during the heat and humidity of 100+ degrees, stayed true during downpours, and survived cooling sprinklers.

For me, at least, this mascara was definitely NOT waterproof, non-smudging or non-clumping. However, you might want to consider mascaras that aren't actually labelled "waterproof", unless you're planning to go swimming w/a full face of makeup, in which case you should check out tarte's new maracuja oil foundation b/c it truly stays put! The two mascaras I use the most (tarte & Buxom) don't claim to be waterproof, BUT they withstand watery eyes & even a few tears surprisingly well, so you might not need a waterproof mascara as much as you think you do -- I certainly didn't! If you find you really do need a mascara that's actually waterproof, you might want to try one of the newer "tubing technology" mascaras, like Becca's Ultimate or DHC's Perfect Pro, since they are made to stay on until you massage them off, yet are still gentle. A lot of the waterproof mascaras out there are not only unnecessary for most women's daily needs, but also contain ingredients that are harsh on your lashes &/or eyes. Hope that helps!

It IS smudge proof. I know from experience it is at the very least tear-proof. I also have straight lashes. I have found that by bending my head back as far as possible while applying Lash Perfection Gel, I will get a more curl or bend in my lashes that lasts all day.

No smudging

In my opinion this is very long lasting, without smudges!

I wear contact lenses and it is no problem whatsoever.

No problems for this contact wearer!

I wear this mascara with my contacts every day and have never had a problem

I've had eyelash extensions and was told to avoid anything with oil in it. I'm not sure how this would work with extensions but it does come off very easy, which hopefully won't pull too much at the extensions. It also isn't runny, so I don't think it has that much of the oil.