I have tried both and I feel the fresh one is a lot more refreshing on the lips when applied but slightly more greasy than the lip conditioner but nothing extreme. Both have similar long term effects on my lips such as long term hydration, smoothness, plump. The onl;y difference is the fresh is slightly more refreshing when applied than the caudalie and is more of a night time lip product as I use caudal during the day while I am out!
answered 2 weeks, 6 days ago
I actually have both the caudalie & the sugar. The Caudalie is nice & inexpensive. However, if you're like me, you end up having to reapply it a lot and the after taste is not so nice. But, the Sugar makes lips very soft and lasts much longer on lips & the benefits are longer lasting as well. Plus, there is no weird taste, after taste or smell. It is a bit pricier but it is actually much better in the long run.
answered 11 months ago
No doubt about it Sugar is way better. There literally is not a comparison!!
I tried both when my lips were wind burned from a long day sailing. Sugar is the best and now I would never dare to try anything else.
answered 1 year, 2 months ago
I've used the Caudalie lip treatment before ... The Fresh Sugar lip treatment feels heavier on the lips but lasts significantly longer than the Caudalie one. Also, I found that my lips returned to their dry flaky state once the Caudalie lip balm 'evaporated' from my lips (so I had to constantly reapply).. Not so with the Fresh Sugar. My lips were fully hydrated even after the lip treatment dried off my lips. Definitely worth spending more...
answered 1 year, 5 months ago
I would pass on the sugar lips, save yourself the money and disappointment. It dries out your lips.
answered 1 year, 6 months ago
I have used both and I would pick Fresh over Caudalie. The Caudalie product doesnt last long enough and I had a hard time getting used to the scent they put in it. The fresh lip products have a really nice lemony citrus flavor that I never get tired of.
answered 1 year, 11 months ago
I haven't used the Caudalie one, but if you love it - i wouldn't switch. I love the Sugar Rose one, and was excited about trying this, but it did nothing for me and irritated my lips some. (I do love the Super Coconut Lips - I don't have the title quite right, but it comes in a little jar. LOVE that).
answered 2 years ago
I have used both products and prefer Fresh. The texture is more moisturizing and seems to work better for my dry, chapped lips. In my opinion, the Caudalie was just not moisturizing enough.
To be Honest, I feel like sticking w my Caudalie over any of the Fresh lippies, including the new Advanced one, Why? Because I just get better results w Caudalie when I use it as a treatment, I want something that I can put on overnight that hydrates, nourishes and most of all STAYS ON! I do think Fresh makes some awesome products but seriously, if I was FORCED to choose, I'd go w $12 Caudalie which I hv been using for the past few yrs. I hv every color of Fresh (Except the Passion and Honey) along w the newest Advanced Treatment that contains the plumping spheres. I hv an issue w collecting them but then I never even use them beyond 1-2 Times...yet Ive been through countless Caudalie and panic if I get low so I always hv 1 or 2 extra on hand, It just plain delivers. I hv been using the new Fresh Advanced Treatment but Im pretty positive I will not be repurchasing. To be Honest, the signature Fresh scent isnt even all that great and it sometimes gives me sinus headaches. I bought my mom and myself the Advanced for Christmas and we use it at night. I wanted to pamper her w something that would plump also, she seems to like it enough, but I still find myself reaching for Caudalie, esp at night since I know it will stay on. I actually used up (I didnt want to waste it!) my original Fresh SPF Lip tube by massaging it into my hands a few Times, which was a lovely and nourishing experience....but since then I hv given the Plum to my mom (the color suits her better and she seems pumped about Fresh now) and just keep the Rose in my purse (it shows NO color on me and my skin and lips are fair, but I'm not going to rub Rose into my hands!!) just incase I get caught without any lip SPF which is super important. As for the plumping action, I do wear the Advanced every day and apply at least twice but once this tubes finished I think I'll go back to LipFusion.
answered 2 years, 1 month ago
(That City by The Bay)