What it is:A collection of a long-wear brow pencils with a wingtip comb. What it does:These retractable pencils create fuller looking, perfectly-defined eyebrows. To dispense color, twist the pencil and the always-sharp tip comes up. Easy-to-hold, it gives you perfect control to create precise hair-like strokes. Use the comb tip to brush brows and blend. Available in four natural-looking colors, each long-wearing formula stays put without smudging. What it is formulated WITHOUT:- Parabens What else you need to know:This product is made without mineral oil, preservatives, or animal-derived ingredients.

Questions & Answers:

17 Questions

73 Answers

Ask a New Question

Overall Rating:

4.4

out of

Read All 621 Reviews621

Questions & Answers for SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

Question

I have black hair.. Is midnight brown the right color for me?

asked 11 months ago

Anonymous

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

7 answers

Answers

answer 1

Yes, I personally suggest the shade 04 Midnight Brown for your dark hair.

answered 3 months, 2 weeks ago

melissabt

answer 2

Yes, if that is the color of the darkest shade, then yes. I have dark, dark, brown/black hair and black brows and I find this color to be very flattering on me. :-)

answered 5 months, 3 weeks ago

hollyluvsaustin

(Hutto, TX)

answer 3

yes, I have black also and it works perfect.

answered 6 months ago

claudymkuplvr

answer 4

I have black hair and black eyebrows. I was afraid that the midnight brown would not be dark enough but it definitely it. Apply it lightly for a subtle look and layer it for intense brows. This color should work for you.

answered 7 months ago

atereece

(Tucson, AZ)

answer 5

I think it will be too light for you. I found it too light for me and I have black hair.

answered 7 months ago

asianmk

(Los Angeles)

answer 6

I would say so because if you use a black product to fill in brows it tends to look too harsh. one shade lighter would be perfect in my opinion

answered 8 months ago

skitts

(houma,LA)

answer 7

My eyebrows are pretty close to black, but any black brow pencil I've tried ends up looking atrocious. Midnight Brown is the most perfect shade I have come across. It blends in with my natural color, not too brown, not too black. Hopefully it works the same way for you!

answered 10 months ago

kelsiege

(Seattle, WA)

Question

Is it "rubproof"?

I've tried a few brow products and although they may claim to be long wearing or waterproof, most all have rubbed off very easily. How's this one? Any other brands recommended for staying put until removed? I'd rather avoid a complicated three-part process! Thanks :)

asked 1 year, 8 months ago

artemis917

(lake oswego, or)

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

Hello,

For grey hair color, I recommend the shade 1 or 2.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

melissabt

answer 2

Hello,

I would say that it is waterproof once the product is applied and sets.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

melissabt

answer 3

I wouldn't call it "rub-proof". I personally have never streaked it when scratching my face but it can be "dimmed" if you scratch or rub on the area. I've never had a product that does stay put all day if I touch the area, however.

answered 1 year, 6 months ago

jame43

(Pittsburgh, PA)

answer 4

Most of it would come off if you rubbed it, especially with a kleenex or something. It stays on pretty well for me. If I get caught in the rain and dont rub it, it will stay put. It is better than most. A regular pencil will come off me, but this one is pretty good. I hope this helped..

answered 1 year, 6 months ago

marybella

(Grand Rapids, MI)

answer 5

The longer you have the brow pen on, the easier it will be to rub off (from my experience) because you face get's oilier throughout the day. To keep them on as "permanently" as I can. I recommend first using a good quality pencil and then going over with good quality powder. And touching up after long hrs or before special occasions.

answered 1 year, 6 months ago

therater

(Las Vegas, NV)

answer 6

Since I've been using this brow pencil, it has not smeared or ran. It claims to be waterproof and I believe it.

answered 1 year, 7 months ago

bogart7

(Freehold, NJ)

answer 7

it is! it is very durable and easy to apply

answered 1 year, 7 months ago

michelleohayon

(Alexandria, VA)

answer 8

Comes off with the wipe of your finger. Not waterproof or smudgeproof at all !!!!

answered 1 year, 8 months ago

mytito

(New York, NY)

Question

Need help with color

I'm a medium blond - blue/green eyes with light-medium skin tone - yellow undertones - I'm over 40 a few greys in my brow - I wasn't quite sure which
light brow pencil would be best - I wanted to purchase a brow pencil that wouldn't be harsh looking in the outside light.
Thnks

asked 2 years ago

frazier1

(Cary, NC)

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

7 answers

Answers

answer 1

Once I apply in the morning..I NEVER even have to think about it again throughout the day.

answered 8 months ago

ronac

(Catskill, NY)

answer 2

For your hair color, I would suggest the shade 01 Honey Blonde.

answered 1 year, 1 month ago

melissabt

answer 3

Try going with the lightest shade possible, you can always add on color as this pencil has a very build-able color. I light skin with brown hair and the light blonde color works perfectly for me. This is the best pencil I've ever used! :)

answered 1 year, 9 months ago

smashash

(Manhattan Beach, CA)

answer 4

I've heard people say medium brown is the universal color and is normally the safe way to go. Also you are right about not wanting to it to be to harsh, so going a shade lighter than your natural eyebrow is good too.

answered 1 year, 9 months ago

realisticmisses

(New York)

answer 5

since shephora has such a great return policy i would try one and if it doesnt work move up or down a shade

answered 1 year, 10 months ago

glamstar

(ca)

answer 6

The retractable brow pencil is great - it's easy to use, doesn't go on too heavy, and the tiny brush really helps in making your brows look good. Try to find a shade that is close to your natural hair color, or it will look fake.

answered 1 year, 10 months ago

vasm

answer 7

I think you will love this product. I have very similar coloring to yours. I am fair and have strawberry blonde hair. Not too much gray in my brows, but I yank those suckers anyway!

answered 1 year, 11 months ago

ohsoccermom

(Lakewood, OH)

Question

Colour Help for Dark Hair!

I have very dark hair (near black but still in the dark brown range), very dark brown eyes and dark brown/ black eye brows. Which colour would work best with my eyebrows?

asked 1 year, 4 months ago

alpi

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

7 answers

Answers

answer 1

For your hair color, I suggest the shade 04 Midnight Brown.

answered 1 year, 1 month ago

melissabt

answer 2

I think the 03 Rich Chestnut will work and not look too dark .

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

princesstres

(Houston, TX)

answer 3

I have it in the midnight brown and it is a very nice rich brown with no red under tones. I think it would work perfectly with the description you gave of your coloring , Its a nice pencil and good value !

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

lisami07

(Syracuse, ny)

answer 4

Hi! Midnight Brown (04) should work perfectly for you. Good luck!

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

Katiebella0x

(Boston, MA)

answer 5

Second darkest or darkest color would probably work best, but it also depends onm how much you are filling in. if it's just a teensy bit, go lighter.
Otherwise, you may want both. You didn't say your skin color, but I am fair, (very) with almost black hair that I lighten a bit. I use a medium brown and a chestnut color. in the mid brow I use the lighter color, and to fill in the edges I use a darker color. GL!

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

victoriahvh

(STL, MO)

answer 6

Use a shade that's slightly lighter than your natural brow color. If you use the actual color of your eyebrows, then it might look a little over-dramatic. Hope that helps!

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

krishhhten

(SF Bay Area, CA)

answer 7

definitely the midnight brown.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

auzin

Question

I have black hair (so are my brows) and I prefer more cool browns is the midnight brown shade cool or a warm brown?

I hate using warm browns because they have a reddish tint and I don't like the way they make my brows look but I don't want a black brow pencil because it would be too harsh.

asked 1 year, 5 months ago

ta23

(San Fransico,CA)

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

6 answers

Answers

answer 1

This is a cool brown. It is really a great product

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

ANivia

(Jacksonville, NC)

answer 2

it a cool brown.. thankfully no reddish, auburn undertone. I have veeery dark brown hair & its perfect for me

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

msjaim

(chicago, IL)

answer 3

I think the midnight brown in the Sephora collection will work great for you. If possible try it in the store and see if I am right.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

prsnyc

(New York, NY)

answer 4

it's a cool brown. there is no reddish tint.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

auzin

answer 5

I have Rich Chestnut which is definitely a warm brown.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

emgem

(Nashua NH)

answer 6

I use midnight brown and its a warm brown on me. I work at Sephora and if you have black hair I think this will work well for you!

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

derekinky

(Louisville, Ky)

Question

Non- WaterProof Quality?

Does this eyebrow pencil work just as well non-waterproof or does it wear off during the day?

asked 4 months, 1 week ago

iamloved

(City of Love)

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

6 answers

Answers

answer 1

Lasts all day and night. You will love it!

answered 3 months ago

kaching

(Las Vegas, Nevada)

answer 2

it does not smudge at all during the day!!! it stays true!!

answered 3 months ago

madridla

(New Orleans, LA)

answer 3

It lasts pretty long, i put it on at 8:30 am and it's still on at end of day, I might touch it up before I goto drinks or dinner at 8.

answered 3 months, 2 weeks ago

blackneko

(New York, NY)

answer 4

I find this pencil much better than non-waterproof pencils, and yes, it lasts all day. In fact, it doesn't smudge or come off until I take it off with makeup cleansing cloths. You can't go wrong trying this product!!!

answered 3 months, 3 weeks ago

kk355

(Memphis, TN)

answer 5

For me, this product does not last quite all day. My skin does not maintain other makeup very well (including but not limited to foundation, eye makeup, etc). It's a great beginner product but I probably won't repurchase it because it does not last all that long.

answered 4 months ago

smec

(Seattle)

answer 6

it does not wear off. ive found that if i put it on firs,t like after my toner but before my moisturizer and foundation it lasts all day long!

answered 4 months ago

asher2007

(san francisco ca)

Question

Retractable Brow Pencil

Appears there is very little product in this pencil. Any chance you would have refills available?

asked 1 year, 10 months ago

Anonymous

(Lima Ohio)

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

4 answers

Answers

answer 1

Only a dew companies do refills so far... Hourglass, and Dior come to mind. I wish more would, though!

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

victoriahvh

(STL, MO)

answer 2

This product seems like it has very little in it, but it last for a long time, at least 4 months for myself. It's a very good product, and it's such a good price for such a good product.

answered 1 year, 9 months ago

smashash

(Manhattan Beach, CA)

answer 3

This lasts longer than you'd think - I'm at least a month into my pencil and it hasn't run out yet - the fact that the point is so fine seems to use up less of the pencil with each use.

answered 1 year, 10 months ago

heatheradair1

(Seattle, WA)

answer 4

The Sephora Collection Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof is not refillable. We'll be sure to forward your request to offer refills in the future.

answered 1 year, 10 months ago

1877SEPHORA

(San Francisco, CA)

Question

What color brow pencil color when you have grey hair

asked 1 year, 9 months ago

nootsi

(Cedar Rapids, Iowa)

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

4 answers

Answers

answer 1

For grey hair, I suggest the shade 02 Nutmeg Brown. Its the perfect taupe color that will match your hair color.

answered 1 year, 1 month ago

melissabt

answer 2

An ash brown or a grey pencil would be best. there are lots of ash brown colors, only a few greys. I'd try both kinds, and go OUTSIDE to check it out. GL!

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

victoriahvh

(STL, MO)

answer 3

Hi! Depending on your shade of grey, choose the shade closest to your natural hair color. If you're light grey, go for the blonde, a darker grey, go a shade darker. Go as close to your natural brow color as possible.

answered 1 year, 7 months ago

stacyg321

(Beltsville, MD)

answer 4

they say that even a regular #2 pencil, is good for gray hair...makes sense and i used to actually use one years ago when my hair was gray. I use the midnight brown in this , the darkest shade and think it would be fine with gray hair...you can apply it either lightly or heavily, and lighter it would go well with gray hair I think.

answered 1 year, 7 months ago

jmwr

(TX)

Question

best shade for auburn hair

do any of the pencils have an auburn tint?

asked 1 year, 3 months ago

ludlow

(West Yarmouth, MA)

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

4 answers

Answers

answer 1

For auburn hair, I suggest the color 03 Rich Chestnut. It has more red undertones to it. The other shades will have cooler undertones and will not work as well for your hair color.

answered 1 year, 1 month ago

melissabt

answer 2

Rich chestnut

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

mospuds

answer 3

The sales associate used this one on me specifically because I have some red/auburn in my hair. It's a great match.

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

bonbon24

(Chicago, IL)

answer 4

If you have fair skin and naturally auburn hair and don't want very dark, defined eyebrows, I'd say this pencil in honey blonde would be perfect for you. I found the honey blonde to be a bit too reddish, warm-toned for me since I'm a blonde who looks best in cool, icy tones, but I think this would complement your hair in a very natural way.

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

blurooferika

(SF Bay Area, CA)

Question

Blonde ?

I currently use a "blonde" pencil. I have very light hair naturally. However, my current blonde pencil, is sort of dissapearing on my face, because of my tan. Will the next color up be to dark ?

asked 4 months, 1 week ago

Espojen

(WH)

on Retractable Brow Pencil - Waterproof

4 answers

Answers

answer 1

I think the blonde color in this product is a bit darker than other blonde brow pencils, so you might want to give it a trie. Before I purchased the blonde pencil, I had first bought the next color up but it turned out to be too dark for me and I exchanged it for the blonde.

answered 1 month, 3 weeks ago

nancs

(Oakton, VA)

answer 2

The next color up is a lite brown color, perfect for blonde/brown hair. This pencil is a must have and is the best pencil I have ever used!

answered 3 months ago

kaching

(Las Vegas, Nevada)

answer 3

Try the Nutmeg Brown. It is a very light brown color

answered 3 months, 1 week ago

cherlyann

(shamong, NJ)

answer 4

I don't think the next shade would be too dark. If you are tan, a darker pencil will look perfect to balance everything out. A light brown should do the trick!

answered 3 months, 4 weeks ago

goldielips

(West Palm Beach, FL)

1 | 2 | ...next