What it is: A long-wearing mascara that curls lashes instantly and over time.What it does:This mascara features innovative lash-curl memory that continually curls lashes throughout the day and a proprietary curling resin that dries down and holds the curl of lashes for long-lasting results. A unique brush coats and extends each individual lash for eye-popping results. Its intense carbon black hue delivers a lush, dramatic lash line from base to tip.

Questions & Answers:

3 Questions

13 Answers

Ask a New Question

Overall Rating:

2.6

out of

Read All 95 Reviews95

Questions & Answers for Stila Forever Your Curl Curl Memory Mascara

Question

I want curling with no flaking

I am looking for a mascara that will curl my long lashes but not flake and preferably not smudge....it this one for me? Any recommendations? Thanks!

asked 1 year, 11 months ago

temperance13

(Coltons Point, MD)

on Forever Your Curl Curl Memory Mascara

9 answers

Answers

answer 1

No. This stuff is smear city. Try Blink - it's natural looking and doesn't make you look like a raccoon!

answered 4 months ago

MuffyStJohn

(Washington, DC)

answer 2

try smoky lash by make up for ever. i have not had any problems with it smudging or flaking (unless I cry, then I'm a mess!) it's the best curling mascara i can find right now, and I am testing them all!!

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

kristisb

(San Jose, CA)

answer 3

Best curling mascaras that I have found are Bare Minerals curling mascara and Urban Decay curling mascara. Did not like Stila one bit. It didn't curl and it smudged like crazy!

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

crr1126

(Austin, TX)

answer 4

If i want curl i use sexy curves from Rimmel...honestly its the best for curling over any high end mascara

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

steph0726

(Oak Lawn, IL)

answer 5

NO! I just posted a one-star review on this mascara today. I loved that the tiny brush let me get at every angle of my lashes, but that was the only upside of this product. Not only does this not curl your lashes, but it doesn't hold the curl when you use an eyelash curler. It also smears really horribly--be prepared to look like a raccoon. That and the $22 pricetag just isn't worth it.

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

kimnessa

(Beavercreek, OH)

answer 6

Like you, I also have long lashes & I use this mascara every day, as a base for my other favorite (Rimmel's Accelerator). I have read that some have trouble with it clumping & smearing, but I haven't noticed any problem with it. The longer, narrow applicator makes it easier to apply in detail, as well...and the curl memory is really good.
Try it & I don't think you will be disappointed. :)

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

jenndef

(Sterling Hieghts, MI)

answer 7

I'd say stay away from this mascara. It smudged like crazy on me and did not have any curling effect at all.

answered 1 year, 7 months ago

beccafly

(Boston, MA)

answer 8

If you are looking for a mascara that doesn't smudge, I'm sorry to say keep looking. I had racoon eyes an hour after application with this one.

answered 1 year, 8 months ago

pinkblossoms

(Georgia)

answer 9

I don't recommend it at all. It smudges, smudges some more and then it keeps smudging.

answered 1 year, 10 months ago

cayb

(Orlando, FL)

Question

It smears and I get black circle under my eyes

Why does this mascara smear I already have dark circles this mascara makes them look worse.

asked 1 year, 8 months ago

dgdl

(Cypress,CA)

on Forever Your Curl Curl Memory Mascara

3 answers

Answers

answer 1

Honestly, because it's a bad mascara. It just sucks and there is nothing good about it. A really great mascara is Diorshow or Lancome Hynose.

answered 1 month, 3 weeks ago

TifaniNikol

(pensacola, fl)

answer 2

This product smudged beyond belief. I found that Bare Minerals curling mascara and Urban Decay curling mascara are much better at both curling and less smudging.

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

crr1126

(Austin, TX)

answer 3

This mascara gave me dark circles under my eyes as well. That never happens with waterproof mascara for me so I am switching back.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

avari

(Toronto, ON)

Question

How does Stila's Forever Your Curl compare to Tarte's Ligts Camera Lashes?

I've been using Stila's FYC and have never tried Tarte's LCL. I'd love to know if LCL provides the same curling effect as FYC? LCL has a much higher rating and im willing to convert as long as it will stil curl my lashes without having to use an eyelash curler!! THANKS DOLLS! XoXo

asked 5 months, 1 week ago

SimplyChelleXx

(Maryland)

on Forever Your Curl Curl Memory Mascara

1 answer

Answers

answer 1

I really did not like Stila's Forever Your Curl. I hated how clumpy and heavy it was, it also made my eyes sting. Tarte LCL was better but it still wasn't the holy grail of mascara. I'd say Tarte is a better choice. However, the best I've used to date is actually Diorshow (or Loreal's Voluminous, which is a great dupe).

answered 1 month, 3 weeks ago

TifaniNikol

(pensacola, fl)

1 of 1