Comparison with Fresh Sugar
I've been using Fresh Sugar's Rose for a couple of years, but it is pretty pricey (about CDN $30 with tax) and I tend to go through a tube pretty quickly. This is a lot cheaper, and I'm wondering if anybody's compared the two products in terms of hydration and moisture?
asked 1 year, 1 month ago
on Chubby Stick Moisturizing Lip Colour Balm
I have and the Sugar Product is much more moisturizing (Probably why it's so much more expensive). Chubby sticks are good for a pop of color but they don't offer the same level of moisturizing as Sugar Treatment.
answered 2 weeks, 3 days ago
I use Fresh Sugar's lip treatment at night and the Chubby by day--in combination it works very well. The lip treatment does not come off during the night and my lips feels great in the morning.
I too have a couple of tubes of Fresh lips - Fresh has a great lemony smell but this Clinique in the Melon color is a great color! So easy to apply even without a mirror too.
I have also tried Fresh's Rose lip balm and I really enjoy the chubby sticks more bc you can get light to dark colors to choose from and these are much lighter feeling on your mouth. They do moisturize as well
No comparison. Clinique really knows what they're doing with lip products. I've tried Fresh's Sugar products and it is definitely a short-term relief from dryness. Not at all as long-lasting as this one!
answered 7 months ago
Sugar has more silky texture than this one...
Sugar smells better and tastes better too....
But sugar likes to melt and goes super soft big time in 80 degree weather... :S
I like the sugar rose color more than chubby stick's pink tones
answered 10 months ago
(Salt Lake City)
I have both products and would say that the Fresh Rose has definitely more of a slick texture and just adds a light hint of color that blends well with the lips. The chubby sticks are a little closer to a lipstick. They have the texture of a more waxy chapstick but are still quite hydrating and with a hint of shine (a good compromise between lipgloss and lipstick. I usually like a little more structure to the formula than the tinted chapsticks. After the product has rubbed off you will be left with a bit of a stain -whereas with Fresh you would have to reapply. You can build up the color a bit with these and i feel like they are less likely to melt in your purse during the summer months.