I have both products and would say that the Fresh Rose has definitely more of a slick texture and just adds a light hint of color that blends well with the lips. The chubby sticks are a little closer to a lipstick. They have the texture of a more waxy chapstick but are still quite hydrating and with a hint of shine (a good compromise between lipgloss and lipstick. I usually like a little more structure to the formula than the tinted chapsticks. After the product has rubbed off you will be left with a bit of a stain -whereas with Fresh you would have to reapply. You can build up the color a bit with these and i feel like they are less likely to melt in your purse during the summer months.

You don't need to sharpen this; it's like chapstick. You twist the silver base when it runs low, and that will give you more.

I think it does. For me, it's a little to gooey and doesn't give me the definition I want from a pencil, chubby or otherwise.

As a fellow lover of Tenderheart, I would probably go with Honey. I feel like Fig might be a little too "pinky."

whole lotta honey and heaping hazel nut. Heaping hazel nut is truly nude shade and whole lotta honey is little darker than heaping hazel nut. I love both of them. I have fair med skin tone.

no

Heaping Hazelnut and Pure Strawberry are great neutral and rosy everyday colors.

I also have very fair skin with pink undertones with Auburn hair. I own several of these colours and my favourites are Richer Raisin, Whole Lotta Honey, and Heaping Hazelnut. Those cover the whole spectrum from dark to nude and they match my skintone really well. Hope that helps!

No the stick is way to big to be a liner but a good undertone.

Clinque Chubby Sticks are actually VERY mosturizing! I would recommend some light berry colors like Super Strawberry, Wopping Watermelon, or Pretty Peony and brown colors like Raisin. Hope I Helped! :)