This, or Benefit's Eye Bright?
Has anyone tried both? It seems like they both have the same purpose - to brighten and wake up your eyes, but is one better than the other in color, texture, application, staying power, etc?
asked 4 years, 9 months ago
on Lights, Camera, Lashes™ Inner Rim Liner
Def go with Benifit. Tart's does not have an easy application as the pencil breaks and cracks with application.
I've used both and prefer this peachy color and small, twist up applicator. One application lasts about three to four hours. The benefit pencil is probably a little more hygienic.
answered 2 years, 4 months ago
I bought the Tarte brand first. It stayed on well, but decided I did not like the nude/flesh color since I was used to putting a dab of pink eye shadow in the inner corners of my eyes. I ordered the Benefit pencil and have used only a few days. However, I love the pink color much better and can use one product in both places (tear line and inner corners). I need a couple more wearings to decide if the Benefit product is as long-lasting.
I use my other eye brightener on the outside of the eye. This is the only safe for inside of eye I believe. I like the natural look.
answered 3 years ago
(Rancho Cucamonga, CA)
Two completely different products. Benefits eye bright is more of a liquid that you blend into the skin around the eye and it brightens (really like). This EmpahsEYES goes on the lines just inside the eyelashes closest to the eye ball. It goes on easy and stays put. Both together would be amazing.
answered 4 years, 2 months ago
(San Francisco, CA)
I use the eye bright around my eyes to perk them up but not in them. The Tarte product is less pink than the benfit product which I would think would de-emphasis any redness.
answered 4 years, 3 months ago
I ran out of benefits eye brightener so I bought this instead & I was disappointed. I returned this products & purchased the eye brightener. Also, the high brow by Benefit is a winner in my book.
answered 4 years, 4 months ago
I have use both liners.... the benefit is much more pink/white... whereas the tarte is a bit more neutral (I like the color better). If you are purchasing to use on inner rim f eye, be aware that is staying power is not great....
answered 4 years, 5 months ago
(Grand Rapids, Mi)
I like Tarte on the waterline and the Benefit for under the brow. The thick pencil and the hardness of the Benefit formula make application on the waterline difficult.
answered 4 years, 6 months ago
(San Francisco, Ca)
similar in color but tarte goes on much more smooth....the benefit liner though will last you 4 times as long....i have both and i would say pricewise go with benefit but for quality go with tarte
answered 4 years, 7 months ago
I tried this one, but I'm returning it and trying the Benefit one.
answered 4 years, 8 months ago