You are correct on the last part of your statement. If you have good skin then just use the foundation stick for extra coverage, not blemishes. This is great for broke capalaries and blemishes, the other is not oil free.

The sales person told me they are different. I bought both and noticed the touch up stick (small one) is a bit more creamy than the foundation stick. So the texture is a bit different. The sales person told me this was meant for a face concealer (blemishes, age spots, etc.). Not to be used under the eye (although I tried this, and it didn't seem to badly drying, in fact I wouldn't use it under the eye again due to creasing. I did use it around my nose and it works pretty good.

I use it the same as if it were the bigger foundation stick.. I layer to camo.

This is a totally different product from the Foundation Stick. The Foundation Stick is indeed a foundation, to be used all over the face. This Face Touch Up Stick, is a spot coverage concealer, it is not an all over foundation. The Face Touch Up Stick is great for covering blemishes, broken capilaries, etc. It is NOT an under eye concealer though, this gives a full coverage matte finish, and is much too drying for under the eye area.

It's definitely not a concealer -- it doesn't provide that much coverage. Hope that helps!

It's just not going to work under eyes. Go with the corrector in a bisque color as it is made for under the eyes and forget about her undereye concealer to use on top, don't need it.

you could, but most concealers are too dry for the under eye area. If you want something for under your eyes, I would suggest the creamy concealer kit, which is amazing.

This is great for spot concealer.

Many good concealers do not have a consistency that is creamy enough for use under the eyes -- the skin there is more dry (and does not produce as much moisture as the rest of the face). While this is a great stick to use over the face, it's generally too dry for the under eye area and will look cakey and/or settle into fine lines. For the under eye area, it's generally better to use a concealer that is formulated specifically for use in that area (unless you have an oilier skin type and/or no fine lines / creases).

I noticed that it gets really dry and cakey when you use it under your eyes.

If you have freckles and are that light go with the lightest in BB, I don't know if that is alabaster or procelain.

My skin is light enough that the smashbox one in fair looks right on me, at least under the eyes and the lightest shade (alabaster) is perfect for me, so I would suggest the porcelain. Hope that helps.

I also have pretty fair skin. I tan, but in the colder months, people often comment on how "milky white" my skin is. I use Porcelain and I can't imagine it being too dark for anyone. I think the difference between Alabaster and Porcelain is probably the hue, with Alabaster being more pinkish than Porcelain. So if you always burn in the sun rather than tan, I would choose Alabaster. Otherwise, I don't think Porcelain would be too dark.

No, I haven't had a problem.

No, this oil free matte finish formula is ideal for acne prone skin and for covering blemishes.

Go with the bisque color, it is NOT peach. If you are fair go with the sand or lighter.

I have the same problem with most foundations and concealers and the yellow undertones because my skin is fair enough that most of the undertones are pinker than most peoples. This is one of the very few concealers that never turns yellowy or orange and actually comes in a light enough shade. The other brand I would suggest is Make Up Forever: they have dozens of shades and a lot of them are pink-based instead of yellow based. The difference I noticed between those two brands of concealers is that this tends to be a bit thicker and creamier and is great for everything except under the eyes where it can crease a bit and be drying, whereas the Make Up Forever concealer (at least the HD one) is much better for under eye circles and it's thinner so if you layer it and build up the coverage, it seems to not sink into fine lines. I hope this helps!

It covers my little birth marks and blemishes, so it should cover your age spots.

It covers mine on very fair skin, but I lightly retouch a 2nd time on spots

It's a small size of the foundation

golden 6 if you have more yellow undertones

I would really recommend going to the Bobbi Brown display in Sephora and trying several shades on your spots. Then walk outside and see which shade really blends with your skin.

Try the 0 Porcelain-I'm very fair with pink undertones & that works for me!