Question
Film Noir vs. Ultraflesh Panthera
I think I've narrowed it down to two mascaras: Film Noir and Ultraflesh Panthera. However, I can't decide between the two!!! I love the brush on both of these. The only thing is that having to remove Film Noir might be a bit of a problem for me. What would you recommend? Thanks so much!
asked 1 year, 10 months ago
kateincali34
(san diego, ca)
on Film Noir Full Spectrum Mascara
answer 1
I use cleansing oils to remove all my makeup and it works beautifully on waterproof products. Shu Uemura makes a fantastic one, and there are other ones available at Sephora (Boscia, Josie Maran, Sephora brand) that are probably just as good.
answer 2
I remove the Film Noir with baby shampoo. I started doing these years ago when my allergies flared up, and found it does a good job on the mascara too. Suds it up, rub it in, doesn't harm your eyes. Then I take a cue tip at the end to remove any leftover eyeliner, etc.
answered 1 year, 3 months ago
henrymom
(Burlington, Vermont)
answer 3
I was not a huge film noir mascara, felt it was "wet" and go clumpy quick. Ended up only using it a few times, the brush is nice though. Good luck!
answered 1 year, 3 months ago
answer 4
Film noir comes off like any other mascara. I use philosophy purity and no problem. I don't use waterproofs because I dont have the patience to remove them. I have tried an embarrassing amount if mascaras and this is my fave! Buy it!
answered 1 year, 5 months ago
answer 5
I don't think I've tried Ultraflesh yet but this Film Noir mascara is not more difficult to remove than any other mascara that I've noticed. So for now I would say go with Film Noir because it's great!
answered 1 year, 6 months ago
answer 6
I think Bobbi Brown lengthening beats both of these by a long shot if you haven't tried it.
answered 1 year, 7 months ago
supercat
(Pacific Northwest high in the mountain's)
answer 7
I simply love both! I liken them to daytime (Film Noir) and night time (Panthera). I found them both easily removable with an oil based eye makeup remover. They both lengthen and define, with the primary differences being that Panthera is darker than Film Noir and they have different brushes. However, I did find Film Noir to stay the same consistency-wise after a month or so while Panthera got a little bit clumpier. I say invest in both!
answered 1 year, 7 months ago
answer 8
do not waste your money!
answered 1 year, 9 months ago
answer 9
oops, sorry.. I meant 'which mascara would you recommend.' thanks!
answered 1 year, 9 months ago
kateincali34
(san diego, ca)
answer 10
Boscia makes a reasonably priced "oil" that is amazing. It even takes off my Shu Uemera eyeliner
answered 1 year, 9 months ago
answer 11
Almay eye-makeup remover pads (the ones you find in the little plastic container at the drug store). Get the regular kind, NOT the oil-free!
answered 1 year, 9 months ago