Question
natural eye or this?
which palette do you think is better this one or Natural eye by too faced?
asked 2 years, 10 months ago
Anonymous
(San Fransisco, CA)
on Naked Palette
answer 1
I actually have both palettes, and my default everyday eye look is a combination of the two. (Virgin (UD) in the inner corner, Silk Teddy (TF) all over the lid, Naked (UD) on the whole outer half, Buck (UD) in the crease, Sexpresso (TF) on the outer corner.) You can achieve such a wide variety of looks and intensities when you have both palettes. There are, of course, a few similar colors (naked/velvet revolver, sin/silk teddy, smog/push up), but I still find it to be COMPLETELY worth it. If you definitely need to choose just one, the best palette would probably depend on your personal makeup style. The UD Naked palette offers a little bit more all-around variety than the TF Natural Eye, but the TF palette has more in terms of very simple daytime looks. BOTH palettes are fantastic, and if getting both is an option, I'd absolutely go for it.
answered 1 year, 9 months ago
answer 2
i found that the too faced palette was less suitable for everyday wear, even the classic, day colors. it just gave off a oily shiny look. the UD gives a much better, smoother look for any occasion
answered 1 year, 11 months ago
answer 3
UD Naked palette, hands down. Yes, it is more expensive, but you are getting more colors, excellent primer, and a brush. I don't have Too Faced Natural Eye, but I do own Too Faced Naked Eye, and I regret not taking it back. I'm really unimpressed with the quality of the Too Faced shadows, not to mention the ultra cheap cotton applicator it comes with. Please do yourself a favor and go for Urban Decay.
answered 2 years, 2 months ago
steph1231
(Los Angeles, CA)
answer 4
Personally I would choose this. Although you pay just a tad bit more you get more of a variety. With this palette you can create a very natural eye but this palette also contains enough colors to create a smokey eye as well.
answered 2 years, 3 months ago
answer 5
It really depends on what look you desire. Urban Decay is toung in cheek with the title "naked"; even the description says the palette "won't leave you naked". Meaning: if you want the actual, more natural, almost no-eyeshadow, Bella Swan-type look, then you need matte shadows, which "naked" does not offer.
However if you want, a more neutral, yet glam look, then you will want a little more pizazz to your shadows, some shimmer. Althouth too-faced does offer some shimmer neutrals as well "naked', it does not have the same variety nor as many. Thus, this more va-voom version of neutral eye-makeup is more limited with the too faced shadows while the possibilties with 'naked" are more infinite (plus you get some great eyeliner and a deluxe sample of primer).
Bottom Line: If you actually want the true, naked look, the better value is too faced (remember you still get some glitzy neutrals for nighttime). However, if matte shadows do not appeal to you in any way, then spend the extra money on "naked" and you won't be disappointed.
answered 2 years, 4 months ago
answer 6
I have both this and the Too Faced Natural Eye kit. While the Too Faced kit is very nice, it has NOTHING on the UD Naked Palette which has more shadows, a double ended liner pencil and a sample of the Primer Potion for only a small amount more than the Too Faced kit. If I could only have one, it would for sure be the UD Naked Palette. If it's not available where you are, though, then the Too Faced is a good alternative.
answered 2 years, 5 months ago
dancingdream99
(Toronto, Ontario)
answer 7
I own both palettes, love them both, and use both of them regularly. I definitely mix up the Too Faced Natural Colors though. I've created some of my own looks with the shadows in addition to following the directions for the "looks".
answered 2 years, 6 months ago
answer 8
Get them both. I did. Too Faced palette is more cool toned and chic. UD Naked Palette is warmed toned and sophisticated. Both are excellent values and both would look good on most skintones.
answered 2 years, 8 months ago
kindone67
(Terre Haute, IN)
answer 9
Two Faced Natural Eye is great for beginners when it comes to applying eyeshadow because it is totally brainless. They match the colours for you and include instructions. But UD Naked has more variety and product but you will have to be open to trying out different combinations but it is safe to say that all the shades in that palette go well with each other. It is smartly created. Both are good.
answered 2 years, 8 months ago
answer 10
I would say both are good palettes, but Urban Decay is better and you get more for your money. However, something to keep in mind is the Naked palette is mostly warm in tone while the Too Faced palette is more cool.
answered 2 years, 9 months ago
answer 11
I say both. I have both and I love them. I use them all the time. Can't say enough about either one. They are awesome!!!
answered 2 years, 9 months ago
answer 12
I say this becacuse there is a larger variety of colors and the shadows are all full-sized and it also comes with a mini primer potion and a double-ended eyeliner.
answered 2 years, 9 months ago
stealmysunshine
(Left my heart in San Francisco)
answer 13
I plan on getting both. Actually I already own Too Faced's Natural Eye box and I've used it probably almost every single day and my sis and mom borrowed it too. The first three shadows in there are MATTE not sparkly. It seems like the UD ones are all shimmery or sparkly somehow which makes me think "not natural at all" but I havent seen it close up so I could be wrong. If you want something simple, Too Faced. If you want something that allows you to wear a ton of different shades, this one prolly. IDK how big it is IRL so I cant tell you anything about the size and travel friendly wise but the TF one travels pretty well IMHO.
Images for this Answer
(click to see full-size image)
answered 2 years, 9 months ago
nozomiwhitewolf
(St. Louis, MO)
answer 14
I own both palettes and like them both. I love Urban Decay shadows (my usual favorite brand) and in the NAKED palette, anyone can wear these colors. Very neutral and versatile selection. It also has a double ended pencil and a sample primer potion. Sleek packaging too! The Natural Eye kit by Too Faced is GORGEOUS! It's less expensive-but not less quality. But, if I had to choose I'd go for the Too Faced Natural Eye but they are BOTH beautiful sets.
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
answer 15
Not even a question. URBAN DECAY kills Too Faced in anything... I agree with everyone else 1) it's an amazing deal... 2) the shadow pay-off is greater (i find TF to be really cheap and overly sheer..) 3)much better packaging!
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
answer 16
I actually ended up returning the Too Faced Natural Palette because I knew I wanted to buy the UD Naked Palette when it came out. You get more for your money in terms of product (full shadows, broad range of colors, primer potion, eyeliner.) The packaging is also better on the Urban Decay palette for travel. There were several times I wanted to take the Too Faced palette with me, but its a big thick square box - awkward! Urban Decay's palette is slim and wide, like a large wallet - much better! Overall, the shadows are more unique and gorgeous than TF.... Buy UD!
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
answer 17
This one comes with so much more, it is hard to find a neutral and still "sleek" palette that comes with a Black also, I have black hair and brows, so I can use the black for my brows too as well as my crease, and all in one palette.
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
answer 18
I think that the Too Faced Natural Eye Palette is really beautiful and very good, however, this palette comes with a lot more, the colors are full sized, a mini primer potion, and a double-ended eye pencil. This one is definitely a better deal.
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
answer 19
this one!! more colors and it may cost more, but you're
getting more for your money over all:)
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
answer 20
They are both great palettes, it really depends which brand you like better. This one has more eyeshadows AND a liner, so I'd say grab this one.
answered 2 years, 10 months ago
answer 21
I've heard good things about both, but I would personally choose this. I've always preferred Urban Decay's shadows over Too Faced. Plus, I feel this is a great deal. All of the shadows in this are full-sized, and it comes with primer and two liner colors. Also, the packaging on this is much sleeker and seems like it would be easier to take with you or to store somewhere. Hope this helped!
answered 2 years, 10 months ago