I would try something like Melon Daiquiri, if you want something more on the clear side, or Peppermint Bark for something more colored (it's red). Both taste really good and are very shiny. :)

I would try cinnamon buns if you want a clear color with bits of small glitter in it. It is not too overwhelming and will look good on all skin types. Or, vanilla birthday cake.

vanilla birthday cake is my fave, it tastes and smells like cupcakes and is a pretty sheer shimmery gold. melting marshmallow would be my 2nd choice, it tastes and smells like brownies.it's a shimmery clear/frosty color. The only one i didn't like was red velvet cake it's a very pretty dark cherry but tastes horrible

Cherry on Top is good for day & evening.
Also, the Angel glosses are great-minty-vanilla
There's no wrong one

Definitely try Vanilla Birthday Cake first!!! It tastes so good and looks so pretty on everyone!

raspberry sorbet or melon daiquiri. they both smell so good and most people like both of those flavors.

i would suggest picking the color you like best, as the clear is clear and the shimmer adds shimmer.. the color does add a bit of color, etc. they are all glossy with a gloss finish but the subtle differences are noticable. since i like all of the flavors, i pick them by color. the shimmers are really flattering, as is the color.. but to just try one for shine, i'd stick to the clear..

Truthfully, it's up to you! You won't be disappointed with any of the glosses - that's guaranteed! - but you may have a favorite flavor or color, and that may help you narrow your choices a little bit. My first lip shine was Caramel Apple (a yummy, deep red with gold flecks) and I chose it because it was autumn and I was hungry for something a little darker than my summer glosses.
If you're not sure, you should head to your local Sephora and give a few of them a shot! If you're shopping online or you'd rather not test in the store, I'd recommend Melon Daiquiri: it's peachy, sweet, has a little sparkle and shine, and compliments all skin tones.
Enjoy!

That is a tough question. Personally, I like Vanilla Birthday Cake because it smells exactly like a wedding cake right out of the oven. Cinnamon Buns and Red Velvet also have great baked tastes to them. The others are more fruity, and I think of them more as summer flavors.

You should definitely start out with a natural pink/red, like bubble gum pink, of red velvet cake. These don't have a pigmentation like lipstick, but give you a sheer wash of tint, so something that looks natural will be your best bet! I have Vanilla Birthday Cake, and I love it, but it's too sparkly for me.

Around 16 dollars.