I was torn between the two so to test them out, I applied stila to my right eye and Kat Von D to my left eye (they looked the same). First, Stila was way easier to apply for an even cat eye. Second, Kat Von D started to wear off and smudge after 5 hours while Stila stayed put. Once I got home, I rinsed my face with just water and the Kat Von D began to run down my face (which is a con because its supposed to be waterproof)! Anyway, after testing them both out multiple times and through rainy days, itchy allergy eyes, etc.= STILA WINS!
I've used both the Stila and Kat Von D liquid liner pens. I would definitely recommend the Kat Von D one. It lasts forever and I think that the Stila one flakes way too much.
answered 1 year, 9 months ago
I've used both, and I much prefer this one! The brush is better, and this lasts a lot longer (Stila faded VERY quickly on my lower lids). I also find the application to be easier, as you can go over spots without "erasing" them. That was another issue I had with Stila's liner.
answered 2 years ago
I bought this one and returned it for the Stila waterproof liner - MUCH better choice. I also enjoy the cat eye =)
the stila one is great in colors - but this one is what u want- the line is easily fluid- u can fill in easily - i just love this product for every day use,,the stila glam purple colors are fun- but this one has ease of product!!!
answered 3 years ago
Thank you! I drew lines on my hand with both liners in black and the Stila one actually "bled" on my skin because it was so watery! Needless to say I purchased Kat's! :)
i was also debating between the 2 before purchasing the Kat Von D eyeliner. the sales associate showed me & compared both eyeliner sample testers & said that because the Stila one is a felt/marker tip, it pills after repeated use, while the Kat Von D's brush tip does not.