I can't find the Berlin shade anymore, either. That is upsetting, as it has been my favorite for years (since it first became available)! Hopefully it hasn't been discontinued, but it is looking that way. I have found two alternate colors from a different brand that come close to Berlin, though, so I thought you might want to check them out: Stila Long Wear Lip Color in "Treasure" is the closest match I've located and - from that same line - "Phenomenal" is close, but maybe just a tiny bit darker. I hope this was somewhat helpful.
answered 3 months, 2 weeks ago