Buxom Full On Lipstick is my favorite lip product so I check here often. I have just about all of them, even some now discontinued. Haven't seen Fresno offered at Sephora in a while. I just tried Fresno on the back of my hand. It is almost identical to Brooklyn. If I didn't know, I'd think they are the same color. Maybe Brooklyn has a slightly more berry tone to it. San Francisco is a little lighter and pinker. Not as close as Brooklyn but you might like it also. Good Luck!