Personally, I like this toner over those 2 other products. I have the cleanser & the lotion & i didnt see a huge difference. For me, the toner was better than both of them.

I have been using it for over 2 weeks, I do not notice any difference in scars. I have recent acne scars that I am trying to get rid of. If combination, try just using it on your T-zone.

Yes, it made an immense difference.

Switch to this one. It is excellent, but does not burn. I used toners (in a different brand) that worked ok -- but burned a lot. This one works wonderfully, but doesn't burn at all.

I have a very oily T zone and since using this toner I have noticed less oil on my face. Other toners I have tried seemed to cause more oil later on my face but this one doesn't seem to do this. As far as exfoliation, I would say it helps but I use a small facial lufa sponge on my face so not sure which is doing the exfoliation. I have definitely noticed improvement with this toner and it does not burn my sensitive skin or over dry. Hope this helps.

If the toner you are currently using burns, then it probably has a lot of alcohol. This toner is made with Witch Hazel, therefore it's a lot milder and should not sting the skin. This has worked really well at cutting down on oil without over drying. I think it is work the try. At the very least you can ask for a sample in the store. I think it is worth the buy.

I cant speak for exfoliation, I actually just bought it because I loved the cleanser. I have very sensitive skin and find this works perfectly - I have combo skin and need a moisturizer but my skin has NEVER been oily...

I had a problem with burning with other toners as well...I am on my second bottle of this toner and I have not experienced one negative reaction so i would definitely reccomend it. It still picks up dead skin cells and keeps skin clear.

I am oily, this tones did not help. if your looking for more "refreshing" its ok but does not help with oil.

I'm not sure, haven't seen that yet but copper peptide is great if you use it every day.

The murad post acne lightening treaatment really, really helps. It worked so well in two weeks I was shocked.

I have been using this product and have noticed a difference with my acne scars, but I have also used the Brazillian Peel system once a week in conjunction with Amore Pacific Enzyme peel, which is also used for getting ride of acne scarring. So I cannot say that this alone would rid you of old acne scars. You may want to try this in conjunction with a light peel. I would also recommend Ren's Peel...it is very gently and is made out of fruit enzymes which is great for sensitive skin.

It definitely helps lighten them. Depending on the severity, it will take more time, but this certainly works.

I love this toner, but honestly, I haven't seen any improvement in acne scars. It does help prevent future acne, and it helps reduce redness and irritation from current acne. If you're looking to help treat past problems, try Exfolikate. I only sampled the regular--it was too harsh for my skin. But the gentle did help reduce acne and past scaring. Since the regular strength is even more potent, it should do the same.

I have been using this for a few months and have seen no great improvement in my acne discoloration. I don't believe it is strong enough for that. It may help a TINY bit at preventing current healing pimples from scarring so badly.

Yes, it does work on oily skin. It is formulated to help balance your skin. Also, I do not think it's refillable, but it lasts a pretty long time.

This product has worked well my combination (oily t-zone) and acne prone skin. It's keeps acne at bay and I've noticed a difference in oil production. I believe it has helped to clear at my pores and shrink them a bit as well. However, I do not know if it is refillable.

I've been using this for 2 months now (2x daily) and there has been no tightening of pores.

This is probably the best toner I have used. Most times the toner over dries the skin or does not remove the oil. I think this toner does exactly what it says. It's great.

It does work for oily,acne skin but it is not refillable. However, for the price you do get good usage out of it!!

I also used the detox cleanser and the anti-bac lotion. I was never really into toner, so after I finished the bottle that came with my 9!! kit, I decided not to buy more (needed to save some money). That's the only thng I changed in my skin care, and it really affected my skin -- I started getting more breakouts again. After a couple of months, I broke down and bought more toner. My skin cleared up, so I am now a big fan of this toner used with the Detox Daily Cleanser, Anti-Bac Clearing Lotion, and a nice oil-free moisturizer (I use kate's oil free one, or her goat's milk ot another brand).

If your skin is shiny by mid day you should definately try the toner.

I heard that tone balance out the PH levels in your skin. I like to use a tone but some people don't need it if you have oily or combination skin I think it is good to use. you could also use it once a week to detox your skin. but it is not something you need to use.

Whether or not you need a toner depends on what type of cleanser you use, what skin-type you have, and (I recently found out) what kind of water you have. Toners help remove any left over make-up or other particles after you've washed your face. If your skin's normal and you use a good cleanser that removes all makeup, etc. then you might be able to avoid a toner. (The detox cleanser is very thorough with removing dirt and oil.) If your skin is particularly dry or oily, then using an appropriate toner can help hydrate or clarify (respectively). Definitely, I would only recommend this toner for oily to combo skin.

I've been moving a in the last few years (because of work), and I noticed that the type of water I'm using also effects my need for a toner. Currently I have well water, which leaves a residue if I don't use toner. Previously, I lived in a historic building in Charleston, with ancient, rusty pipes, and the water there also left a film when I didn't use a toner.

I am now used to going to spas and having facial techs telling me they have nothing to really do due to my use of toners, high end toners like this one and Estee Lauder's Verite line. Do yourself a favor and get this toner. You wont regret it!

Definitely not, this is alcohol free toner. Feels refreshing!

Yes, but back off until it stops, it takes time for your skin to get used to it. Let it heal, don't over scrub..use it gently and let your face be the judge.

First aid beautycream is good at soothing, also try mixing it with a very gentle natural toner or hyaluronic acid serum. I use the HA serum to soothe and moisturize when I overdo it and get red. Squalene or Argan oil help too..you don't want the red to get dry or it's worse. These oils don't encourage acne.

The clickr spray is great too but also a little hard on skin.

I would have to say no, since this product does not contain and alcohol or fragrance. Witch Hazel is a natural astringent which does not leave you with any burning or tingling affect. You may have had a counter effect based upon the cleaner you used prior to this Toner.

I have not experienced any stinging or burner when using this toner.

I have travelled with it and it did not leak. just in case put a bag around it, but i havent had any issues

Nope! Great dispenser. Think twice about the product, though. Very irritating.

Anytime I tipped it to one side it would leak so it may if it is not standing straight up.

yes! it does unfortunately :(

I have, yes. Also, the Clinic-to-Go resurfacing pads are very effective. The two month in the row regimen was great.

I have not had success with this product clearing up acne scars, though it does help prevent acne and oiliness.

You should use this product before the anti bac lotion. Cleanse your face, use the toner (after patting your face dry), wait 30 seconds for it to dry, then use the anti bac lotion. Follow up with your moisturizer.

I have combo/oily acne prone skin and I use the detox daily wash (AM/PM) follow with this toner (AM/PM). In the morning I use the total vitamin and oil free moisturizer plus KS sunscreen and at night I use the anit bac lotion with the goats milk cream all after I tone. My skin isn’t really oil (just tzone really) but I have noticed that it’s not as oily as before. The toner has witch hazel in it which will help to control oil production

Also another product you may want to try at nighttime before your anti bac is the Purifying Concentrate by Caudalie. It’s like healthy oils for your skin and honestly I didn’t believe this until I tried it but if you put these essential oils on your skin your skin produces less oil cause its more balanced. I used it only a few nights a week and my skin is a lot less oily then before. I notice the difference when I stop using it, my skin gets oiler again.

Hope that helps!

I use this toner and have combo skin on the sensitive side and it works perfectly.

I have dry/combination skin and acne prone skin too. This product didn't irritate me or caused me to break out. If you want a non-harsh toner, get the Clarifying treatment toner from Kate Somerville.