What it is:A rich, plum mascara that intensifies eye color.What it does:Benefit's BADgal Plum highlights your natural eye color while adding length and volume to lashes. Wear it alone to warm up your lashes or add Plum over the original BADgal Black for an extra pop.

Questions & Answers:

15 Questions

109 Answers

Ask a New Question

Overall Rating:

3.9

out of

Read All 715 Reviews715

Questions & Answers for Benefit Cosmetics BADgal Plum Mascara

Question

Is there a waterproof formula for this?

asked 1 year, 6 months ago

chevaldefi

(Canada)

on BADgal Plum Mascara

3 answers

Answers

answer 1

Sadly, no. I really wish there was, as I hate getting purple raccoon eyes.

answered 4 days ago

SnowyOwl19

(Ebensburg, PA)

answer 2

No there isn't. I have checked everywhere including the Benefit Cosmetics site and there is no waterproof for the plum mascara.

answered 8 months ago

kittylee08

(Queens, NY)

answer 3

yes but the waterproof is black.

answered 1 year, 6 months ago

brightspark

(DC)

Question

What would look well with this?

Would this look good with Stila "Kitten" eyeshadow and Stila "Kajal Eyeliner" in the color Amethyst? Do u have any other combinations that look good? Do tell! :)

asked 3 years, 6 months ago

LizzyLu0352

on BADgal Plum Mascara

11 answers

Answers

answer 1

I have used it with shades of bronze and peach, and light and dark grey with amazing results. On my skin I have had to stay away from plum and amethyst with it because it looks a little overwhelming - I think it's the red undertones.

answered 1 year, 8 months ago

ibloom

(Cheyenne, WY)

answer 2

This mascara is such a dark color it goes with everything. I wear a jade eyeliner either by itself or with a light purple/pink Urban Decay shadow.

answered 1 year, 10 months ago

cynnymn

(New Fairfield, CT)

answer 3

I used benefit "get figgy" cream eye shadow and it looked amazing.

answered 2 years, 2 months ago

nrusilko

(Beaverton, OR)

answer 4

It would look good with both of those colours. I don't think that the purple colour is strong enough to conflict with eyeshadows and liners, and I wear it without much worry. I do reccomend wearing it with warm pinks, purples, and even browns. It looks GREAT with shimmery gold eyeshadow!

Hope I helped!

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

alex9621

answer 5

I use the Buxom eyeliner in Amethyst and it looks really nice. Never used the Stila eyeliners but I find that since the Buxom eyeliner is a little bit brighter than the mascara, it makes the eyelashes look very natural even though they are purple! It's not a perfect match, but it definitely looks nice.

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

18psu55

(Happy Valley, PA)

answer 6

Looks fabulous with Too Faced Oeaches and Weezie with Teddy Bear in the outercorner/crease! Pops the plum color and your eyes!

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

sandsacious

answer 7

It would look good with any nude look, or if you are using eyeshadow colors in purple-ish shades, try using it on just your lower lashline for just the right amount of pop.

answered 2 years, 6 months ago

meghanxrino

(Philadelphia, PA)

answer 8

I wear Kitten with everything, so yes, Kitten will work with this mascara. I also recommend a brown eye shadow, such as Lounge by Urban Decay (it has reddish/greenish shimmer which looks awesome with green eyes). I would avoid purple shadow because it may make the plum look too plummy - I would aim for neutral colors to help the plum mascara stand out.

answered 2 years, 10 months ago

keensense

(North Potomac, MD)

answer 9

I wore it with any look but it wasn't that noticeable on me. I liked it because it was fun and different.

answered 2 years, 10 months ago

jenifer1128

(San Francisco, CA)

answer 10

This looks great with soft, neutral shadows. Like those in the two faced natural eye kit, and plum gel liner.

answered 2 years, 11 months ago

kmad2011

answer 11

blue eyes

answered 3 years, 6 months ago

nauty

(Riverside, CA)

Question

What will the affects be on Hazel eyes?

asked 2 years, 5 months ago

babypandaluvsu

on BADgal Plum Mascara

11 answers

Answers

answer 1

BADgal Plum Mascara will make your eyes look greener. I love it!!!

answered 1 year, 10 months ago

cynnymn

(New Fairfield, CT)

answer 2

I have hazel eyes and I almost exclusively use this mascara unless I am doing earth tone make up and I wear black. This makes the green in hazel eyes really stand out. I highly recommend for hazel eyes as well as green eyes.

answered 2 years ago

spelch68

(Pittsburgh, PA)

answer 3

Depends on your skin tone and hair color. It looks better with darker hair. My blond friend had it on and I could NOT tell any difference whatsoever, but my brunette friend's eyes just seemed to 'pop'. It's not a huge difference, esp. if your lashes are dark, but it just gives your eyes 'a little something extra' if you know what I mean :)

answered 2 years ago

sami12

(Idaho Falls, ID)

answer 4

I have hazel eyes that usually lean toward greenish and when I layer this over black it really makes them pop. I would definitely recommend if you want to bring out the subtle colors in your eyes.

answered 2 years ago

miniature

(Sacramento, CA)

answer 5

I have hazel eyes and this product makes my eyes seem more green, BADgal plum really makes my eyes pop :)

answered 2 years, 1 month ago

sophienels

(Seattle, WA)

answer 6

I have hazel eyes, and I think it enhances them a bit, especially with brown-tone eyeshadow.

answered 2 years, 1 month ago

emrhs

(Sunrise, Florida)

answer 7

I have hazel eyes and this mascara is wonderful! Don't let the "plum" color scare you - it really lengthens and adds volume to your lashes. I love the stuff!

answered 2 years, 1 month ago

kecki

(San Francisco, CA)

answer 8

Effect will be minimal since the color is virtually imperceptible!

answered 2 years, 2 months ago

missconduct773

(Chicago, Il)

answer 9

It brings out the green pigments in your eyes.

answered 2 years, 2 months ago

nrusilko

(Beaverton, OR)

answer 10

I have blue eyes and was worried that it would look weird too, but it goes on very dark, practically black. It just has a very subtle hint of purple, especially when the tips of your lashes hit direct light. It never looks costume-y if thats what you're worried about! Give it a try, or be safe and go with BADgal Black :) Hope I could help!

answered 2 years, 2 months ago

molly11

(IL)

answer 11

I honestly didnt notice any difference.

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

jodfrom

(St Paul, MN)

Question

How will this look?

I have a brown (almost dark maple syrup-colored) eyes, and I want something that'll make them pop. I read that this would, but I want to be descrete (Not having eyelashes that scream: "Hey! I'm wearing purple mascara"). any way to tell if it would look good? thank you, have a good one.

asked 2 years, 10 months ago

Anonymous

on BADgal Plum Mascara

11 answers

Answers

answer 1

My daughter uses this and has brown eyes. It looks great and not purple at all.

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

pottsgirl

(Broomfield, CO)

answer 2

This will be a great mascara for you. It is a nice rich and deep purple color that looks extremely natural. In fact, I find that it does not even look purple when you put it on, but it certainly gives the eyes a pop and you can tell something is different than just a plain old black mascara. If you want, use a deep purple eyeliner for the full effect that will still look natural, but bring out your eyes even more.

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

18psu55

(Happy Valley, PA)

answer 3

I think you and I might have similar colored eyes. I too was afraid of "obvious purple" but it really is a true plum. I liked how it made my eyes look and to my knowledge no one knew but me that I was wearing "purple". When I applied it, it just made things look better, not competed with my eye color.

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

daisee1203

(Texas)

answer 4

Not only does this mascara not scream. It doesn't even wisper. No pop here. I would pass.

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

Anonymous

(Merritt Island, FL)

answer 5

I think you'll be fine with this-the color doesn't scream anything and is subtle, very pretty.

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

suzyb1

(Salisbury MA)

answer 6

no it is very subtle. a lot of my friends don't even notice it's purple until we are outside. you can wear it alone or on top of black mascara if you are still apprehensive. i love it, I have it in black, purple, and blue!

answered 2 years, 9 months ago

sbqueen13

(CA)

answer 7

It's definitely not too much purple. In fact, at first glance it looks like a brown shade, but more vibrant, and it really made my lashes look lengthened.

answered 2 years, 9 months ago

cfloe

(Knoxville, TN)

answer 8

This actualy doesnt look purple when its on which is good. With brown eyes, this may pick up on the yellow pigments in them to make them pop.

answered 2 years, 9 months ago

00kat00

(Canada)

answer 9

I have deep brown eyes (almost like a dark chocolate brownie), and I find that the BADgal Blue mascara looks well with my eye color. I do have the Plum but it doesn't work for me. I already have long eyelashes and the Plum definitely lengthens them, so that might be a reason why it doesn't necessarily work for me. I also find that when the Plum smears, you get magenta-colored marks under your eyes, which I don't like. The Blue works better for me, and it's supposed to do the same thing as the Plum. Hope this helps!

answered 2 years, 9 months ago

KaylaAllain

(New Orleans, LA)

answer 10

If anything I think it will be too subtle. I wouldn't worry about it being obvious as I can barely tell I have it on.

answered 2 years, 10 months ago

Melissa1969

(LA)

answer 11

Not to worry, this is a subtle change - almost like going from black to brown mascara. It will bring out the color of your eyes, but won't make you look like you're ready for a rave - instead of a day at the office.

answered 2 years, 10 months ago

keensense

(North Potomac, MD)

Question

Good for a redhead?

I am a redhead and very very pale, so I don't like to wear black mascara since it looks so dark on me. I usually wear brown mascara, but I thought that this may look a little more natural with my haircolor? (Josie Maran made the perfect "auburn" brown shade of mascara but it's been discontinued.) I have grey eyes.

asked 1 year, 10 months ago

purkinjecell

(OH)

on BADgal Plum Mascara

11 answers

Answers

answer 1

I think it would look good on you. It doesn't look purple when you put it on. It just darkens your lashes. I wouldn't use it if it was a harsh black color. It's more like a brown that doesn't look brown. I know it sounds weird but trust me, it will be just perfect for you.

answered 4 days ago

SnowyOwl19

(Ebensburg, PA)

answer 2

probably yes

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

honbun

(flushing mi)

answer 3

I'm am a fair-skinned ginger so I understand. I never use brown but I liked the idea of the plum - mainly from my sister's recommendations. She is also fair skinned, but has a more plum hair color. I like it, but I'm not sure what you are looking for. It softens the look, but it does almost give the sense that you are wearing eyeshadow lining your eyes because the reflecting red pigment kind of blends with your lids from a distance - if that makes sense. I'm not sure if you wear eyeshadow, but I don't normally, so I noticed it. It is definitely less dramatic than black.

answered 1 year, 6 months ago

brightspark

(DC)

answer 4

I think it might look nice on you. perfect contrast of colors :)

answered 1 year, 6 months ago

ala14

(Texas)

answer 5

I had the same problem with black mascara. In my opinion, this is much better than black or brown. I found out about it while watching a video about good eye makeup for redheads. So, fully recommended!

answered 1 year, 7 months ago

exhorteras

(Los Angeles, CA)

answer 6

I'm a red head... strawberry blonde, with green eyes.... love this mascara!

answered 1 year, 8 months ago

marimac0102

(Providence, RI)

answer 7

I have very fair skin and auburn hair and this mascara is great. It's not overwhelming like black mascara is, and it's a little more fun than brown. It has great definition and volumizing properties and seems to be complimentary to all eye colors. If you're near a Sephora store, I would ask to try it out. One thing that really convinced me was to try it on one eye, with your regular mascara on the other to really see the difference.

answered 1 year, 8 months ago

ibloom

(Cheyenne, WY)

answer 8

I too am a red head and this is an amazing color! My eyes are close to hazel and they look awesome when I wear this mascara! Not too dark and not a trendy look.

answered 1 year, 9 months ago

1poopilu

(Estes Park, CO)

answer 9

I am blonde and fair, black mascara is too harsh. This is a great alternative and provides much better results that brown mascara.

answered 1 year, 9 months ago

bellabella5

(Greensboro, NC)

answer 10

I have found that the plum is a really fabulous and versatile upgrade (or replacement!) for a brown mascara. I have medium-brown hair, am very fair, and have green eyes and the plum does wonders. If you're worried about the plum being too out-there or bright, it's really VERY subtle and natural looking!! My best friend who has blonde hair, fair skin, and brown eyes also loves it. It seems to work with many different hair colors and I don't think it would clash with your red hair at all!

answered 1 year, 9 months ago

cgp1

answer 11

BADgal Plum is still a dark mascara- not purple. I have red/auburn hair m fair with green eyes and I love it. I also only wear black mascara, brown looks a little odd on me. Sephora has a great return policy so why not try something different! You may like it!

answered 1 year, 10 months ago

cynnymn

(New Fairfield, CT)

Question

How Will It Look?

I'm a fan of the original badgal and have never tried the Navy or Plum. I have brown eyes and black hair. Most of the reviews don't mention their eyelash colour. If I apply the Plum to my black eyelashes will it look like I'm wearing it? Or will it just seem like I'm wearing black mascara?

asked 3 years, 6 months ago

jadorezrg

(Cerritos, CA)

on BADgal Plum Mascara

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

Mine are black and my hair is very dark brown. When I wear it, I wear it OVER my regular mascara on top, but alone on the bottom lashes. It is NOT noticeably different (like, you don't notice that it's purple) -- it's pretty subtle. I just think it gives your eyes a little something extra so to speak. That said, I'm pretty upset that I spent so much money on this product, so next time I'll buy a cheapie from the drugstore.

answered 2 years ago

sami12

(Idaho Falls, ID)

answer 2

I never wore any color than black mascara, but i got my makeup done and they put the plum BADgal mascara on me and i loved it. It looks like a black mascara from a distance but up close or in the light the purple tone stands out, beautiful.

answered 2 years, 2 months ago

nrusilko

(Beaverton, OR)

answer 3

I have black eyelashes. This would show up when I was outdoors or in the sun. It looked best on my friend who had lighter eyelashes then you could really tell it was purple. But for me, I liked it because it wasn't so noticeable and I could still wear it to work and not look like im 12 playing with purple eyemake up.

answered 2 years, 10 months ago

jenifer1128

(San Francisco, CA)

answer 4

i have black lashes and i apply a white primer or grey primer before putting it on. it really makes a difference. if not, the color does show, but not as well. i love the plum.

answered 2 years, 11 months ago

dcali174

(east islip, NY)

answer 5

Hi,

I've used this on my black lashes on the tips. It's very subtle but brings warmth to my dark brown eyes, but only in certain lighting. It's nice for a change from black mascara. The best effect I've gotten is using this on the tips of my lashes, layered on top of one coat of black mascara for definition. It's fun but not as spectacular as I'd have hoped. Using it on my entire lashes made my eyes look bloodshot.

Hope this helps.

answered 3 years ago

dreamyone

(ATLANTA LOOKS GREAT THIS TIME OF YEAR)

answer 6

I have the navy and the plum. I have dark brown eyelashes. the color is noticeable in with lighting inside, but can look just like black. outside it definitely looks colored.

answered 3 years ago

chulci

(Merced, CA)

answer 7

I have naturally dark lashes as well, and the result is extremely subtle on me. It looks like I'm wearing a very dark red-brown mascara (very natural), but it really brings out the green in my eyes as well. I think it would bring out the warm tones in your eyes, too.

answered 3 years, 1 month ago

jadeish

answer 8

The color will be a lovely mauve addition to your eye color. If there is any blues/greens in the eye, it will be accentuated with this.

answered 3 years, 5 months ago

SyRilla

(La Vergne, tn)

Question

Is the purple obvious?

I want a mascara to bring out my green eyes but not look so obvious. My lashes are a dark blonde/light brown color. Would they look really piurple?

asked 3 years, 6 months ago

kaylalynn91

on BADgal Plum Mascara

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

I don't think that unless your lashes are blond you are going to notice a huge difference. A light brown color? you'll notice it a little. I have black lashes and wear it over top of blackest black on top and alone on bottom. Just makes my eyes seem brighter - give my regular neutral shadowy eyes a little something extra. It's spendy mascara so you may want to try it first if you can OR buy a drugstore purple first to see if you like it! good luck

answered 2 years ago

sami12

(Idaho Falls, ID)

answer 2

I too have hazel eyes and the mascara brings out the greenpigments in tour eyes, i love it.

answered 2 years, 2 months ago

nrusilko

(Beaverton, OR)

answer 3

No, it isn't too purple at all! It's more of a brownish color with plum undertones once it's applied on your lashes.

answered 2 years, 9 months ago

cfloe

(Knoxville, TN)

answer 4

This looks awesome on green eyes! (I have green eyes, I'm not just saying that.) The plum is a subtle color change, like going from black to brown mascara, but there is something in the hue that green peepers really respond to. Don't worry, this plum is work appropriate and won't look like you're ready for a rave!

answered 2 years, 10 months ago

keensense

(North Potomac, MD)

answer 5

It will show up on lighter lashes. Not so much on darker lashes.

answered 2 years, 10 months ago

jenifer1128

(San Francisco, CA)

answer 6

i have green eyes and dark brown eyelashes and the plum is noticeable, so since your eyelashes are lighter im sure it will be really noticeable.

answered 3 years ago

chulci

(Merced, CA)

answer 7

My lashes are a bit darker than yours, but I found the plum to be extremely subtle. I almost can't tell I'm wearing it - it looks almost like a dark reddish brown mascara (very natural) - but it really does make my green eyes pop. I think it may look a little more plum on you, but I doubt it would be too obvious or scream 'purple!'.

answered 3 years, 1 month ago

jadeish

answer 8

My eyelashes and eye color are similar to the colors you described. When you apply the mascara, you can't tell its purple. the color is a deep, subtle plum, so its not a bright purple. i think the only time you can tell its purple is when the sun is hitting your face because that's how my bf noticed it wasn't black. but even then, he complimented them saying it made the green look brighter! it's a good product to use to make your eyes pop out without using eyeliner or eyeshadow.

answered 3 years, 6 months ago

SteLLaRoMero

(Los Angeles, CA)

Question

will this look good on eyes that are navy blue on the outside but a light chopper on the inside?

see question

asked 3 years, 6 months ago

Anonymous

(Groton, MA)

on BADgal Plum Mascara

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

I would think it would look great! I've liked the plum mascara over any other color so far but for extra 'oomph', I wear it over carbon/jet black on top and alone on bottom lashes (my lashes are black anyway). It just adds a little something extra.

answered 2 years ago

sami12

(Idaho Falls, ID)

answer 2

yes, my eyes are the same as your description and I LOVE this product

answered 2 years, 2 months ago

molly11

(IL)

answer 3

This color would look beautiful on those color of eyes it will really make the copper glow and the blue stand out!

answered 2 years, 11 months ago

Kittenla

(Seattle)

answer 4

Hi,

You are so lucky. What neat eye color. I think this will make your eyes pop.

Hope this helps.

answered 3 years ago

dreamyone

(ATLANTA LOOKS GREAT THIS TIME OF YEAR)

answer 5

The colour of this mascara should definitely go with your eyes; the purple is more subtle than dramatic. Just avoid pairing it with purple eyeshadow.

answered 3 years ago

IvanaJC

(Monreal, QC)

answer 6

I think it would look good with any eye color.

answered 3 years ago

chulci

(Merced, CA)

answer 7

I think it would be really pretty. It makes my great/gold eyes brigher.

answered 3 years, 1 month ago

Frances123

(Palo Alto)

answer 8

yeaps

answered 3 years, 6 months ago

nauty

(Riverside, CA)

Question

Good for blue eyes?

I'm thinking about going out on a limb here and trying this out because I heard that plum-colored mascara makes your eyes look brighter and more awake.
But I'm a little worried that this is going to look really weird on me, or that it just won't show up at all. My eyelashes are naturally dark, and I have blue/green/grey eyes.
Would you recommend this product for me? Will the color show up or look goofy? And how does it hold up to regular mascaras as far as quality and value (I don't wear a lot of makeup but I do use Loreal's Voluminous Waterproof mascara right now)? I'm hoping this mascara will actually make my eyes pop while adding some volume (no clumps?)... I don't care much about lengthening because my lashes are pretty healthy and lengthy naturally, but a little fullness is always nice.
Thanks!

asked 3 years, 11 months ago

zephyrhills

(Palm Beach, FL)

on BADgal Plum Mascara

7 answers

Answers

answer 1

I wear this and I have blue eyes. I'm a very fair person and this color is my favorite! It looks more natural than black, but still darkens my lashes and looks amazing! My eyes stand-out in a way that isn't immediately apparent. After trying this, I can't go back to regular mascara. There is just something about it that it makes me look incredible!

answered 2 years, 2 months ago

gennr

(Plattsburgh, NY)

answer 2

I would think that this mascara would add emphasis to your eyes. I've seen it on brown eyes (it really adds sparkle), gray eyes (it made them look larger), and blue eyes (turned them violet).

answered 2 years, 6 months ago

tastingblue

(Colorado Springs, CO)

answer 3

I recommend it for blue eyes, though with green it is more striking. My eyes change from blue to green naturally - I find when I wear this mascara my eyes look more green.

answered 2 years, 7 months ago

gummysmom

(Toronto, Ontario, Canada)

answer 4

answered 3 years ago

dreamyone

(ATLANTA LOOKS GREAT THIS TIME OF YEAR)

answer 5

If you have blue eyes then BADgal plum was made for you! It is very flattering and wearable, not a bright crazy color at all. You are right, wearing plum colors around your eyes intensifies your eye color and will really make the blue and green colors pop! You can also wear original black BADgal lash, and then brush plum on just the tips for a really slight plum color. I say go for it!

answered 3 years, 10 months ago

benefit

answer 6

BadGal plum with blue eyes will add awesome lashes and highlighting your natural eyecolor as long as your lashes are blonde. In my opinion.

answered 3 years, 10 months ago

mariepat20

(Dillingham, Alaska)

answer 7

Definately great for blue eyes! Its the only mascara I will use!

answered 3 years, 10 months ago

Vball4

(Dallas, TX)

Question

Is this suitable for dark brown eyes?

I'm Asian, with light skin and dark brown eyes. Will this make a difference at all?

asked 3 years, 7 months ago

pinksoysauce

(Colorado)

on BADgal Plum Mascara

7 answers

Answers

answer 1

It's pretty subtle, giving you a little something extra on the eyes. I look less tired, and brighter-eyed ('fresher') when I wear it.

answered 2 years ago

sami12

(Idaho Falls, ID)

answer 2

I don't think it makes any difference, it looks good on everyone! :)

answered 2 years, 6 months ago

makeuppjunkie

answer 3

This colour is best suited for green eyes.

answered 2 years, 7 months ago

gummysmom

(Toronto, Ontario, Canada)

answer 4

no difference at all!

answered 2 years, 7 months ago

mellokitty

(Montreal, Quebec)

answer 5

answered 3 years ago

dreamyone

(ATLANTA LOOKS GREAT THIS TIME OF YEAR)

answer 6

I have really dark brown eyes, and I feel like this mascara makes them pop. I love the way it makes my eye color look!

answered 3 years ago

em3415

(New Orleans, LA)

answer 7

Yes, the plum is great. When the light hits your lashes it will bring out any gold flecks in your eyes, it is really pretty. If you are looking for something that will really stand out, I would try the Bad Gal Blue!

answered 3 years, 7 months ago

benefit

1 | 2 | ...next