I would try the lightest one. You can try them on in a Sephora store if you are near one.
answered 2 weeks, 4 days ago
I think #1 should work well for you. I have olive skin and use #2. And #3 and #4 are darker.
answered 5 years, 3 months ago
I'm 45, but it sounds as though our skin and eye coloring is very similar. I bought color 1 Ivory Beige and am very happy with it, but could have gone with either this or the next shade darker - 2 Nude Beige. My suggestion is if you can physically get to a Sephora store, let a beauty advisor help you try it on and make the choice. If not, I think I'd recommend going with the lighter one. While it may look slightly "yellow" in the tube it isn't all all once you apply it: it's very neutral. Good luck! :)
answered 6 years, 2 months ago