Question
HD Microfinish Powder or Bare Escentuals Mineral Veil?
I'm looking for a powder that absorbs oil and minimizes pore. I've tried both powers at Sephora store on the back of my hand and I think the HD micro powder feels more silky. I have fairly toned, combination skin with larger pore on my nose, so which one should I buy?
asked 4 years, 7 months ago
on HD Microfinish Powder
answer 1
This is a tough question for me since I really enjoy both of the products. If I had to choose one, I would go with the makeup forever. I think it is a bit more coverage, and acts more as powder then a finishing powder. it makes my skin a little softer than the bare minerals and doesn't leave any stray powder marks. I love the bare minerals but i find it leaves splotches of powder residue if I don't blend it in too well.
answer 2
Hi - my skin sounds just like yours. i'm 24 fair blue eyed combo skin. BE is my fave makeup, but after trying this, this is gorgeous for fair skin. I found the mineral veil to look a little chalky and pale me out even more, where this is completely transparent and just makes my pores go away. even the nasty nose ones.
answered 1 year, 1 month ago
answer 3
I use both together- I mix 1/2 mineral veil bronzing and 1/2 HD and it works great!!!!
answered 1 year, 8 months ago
answer 4
Mineral Veil is garbage. My aesthetician actually said that it is the WORST product in the Bare Escentuals line - clogs pores, and contrary to popular belief, is somewhat comedogenic.
That being said - the MUFE only slightly mattifies skin. It doesn't absorb excess oil like a blotting paper would. It does however set makeup (works perfectly with the HD foundation) and gives a nice natural finish.
answered 1 year, 9 months ago
beautygrl80
(Long Island, NY)
answer 5
HD for sure. I have both products, and used the mineral veil for years -- and I no longer use the mineral veil. I have oily skin with large pores, and the mineral veil ultimately didn't do all that much. The HD -- if you use it correctly (a little goes a long way) -- really smooths out the skin and adds a little bit of a glow. My mother asked me if I had done anything to improve my skin -- and when I told her that I was wearing the HD, she went right out and bought it (and it did nice things for her 73 year old skin as well).
answered 2 years, 4 months ago
answer 6
HDMP is 100% silica, which is so fine you can set concealer; yep, even if you have crinkles and wrinkles around your eyes - this gives a soft focus effect. I'm more mature and am very careful putting any kind of "powder" around my eyes, but this stuff is fabulous. You just have to use a very soft brush, swirl lightly, tap tap, and very gently blend over your concealer - will last all day and into the night. You can use it as a finisher on your face too. BEMV has starchy stuff in it; like: "Corn Starch, Zinc Stearate,, Magnesium Stearate, Methylparaben, Propylparaben, Mica, [and] May Also Contain: Iron Oxides, Titanium Dioxide."
answered 2 years, 7 months ago
answer 7
Hands down Mineral Veil. While MUFE lasts longer, Mineral Veil is easier to use (i.e. less messy), much more versatile and in my opinion gives much better results.
answer 8
BE all the way!!!! I have used both at length and would pick Mineral Veil way before MUFE. And I usually LOVE MUFE products so this is saying something.
answered 3 years, 3 months ago
answer 9
neither. get silica powder and boron nitride powder, mix 50-50. i make 5 times as much for under 15$.
answered 3 years, 5 months ago
answer 10
Hmmm, it sounds like you were describing my face/skin, girl! LOL
do not worry that the MUFE powder is a bit more expensive.... it is sooooo worth it! I have been using MV for years, and I an very glad that I switched! Absolutely no comparison! An older associate at the store was trying to convince me to stay with MV... but I am in my mid-30s , not in my 60s, and the combo skin is still really rebelling against me. To cut a long story short, give it a try, you could always bring it back.... but you won't, because you are going to LOVE it!!!!!
answered 3 years, 5 months ago
answer 11
I would recommend the HD powder over Mineral Veil (especially the feather light MV) because the MV adds too much shine; MV contains corn starch which can cause breakouts, and it also seems to accentuate dryness.
HD powder is very fine but doesn't seem to cause so much of a mess because the sifter contains fewer and smaller holes that allow just the right amount to come out. It also creates a smoother finish than MV.
answered 3 years, 7 months ago
answer 12
MUFE is better than BE. I have very oily skin and this leaves nicy finish. A little goes a long way and it helps the skin look great. I still have some BE powder, but I don't use it. It is true for me that with BE, I have to apply over and over.
answered 3 years, 8 months ago
answer 13
I own both and I like this HD powder a lot better because it is a lot finer so it is truly invisible on the skin, but it provides a soft focus matte finish that lasts all day long.
answered 3 years, 8 months ago
answer 14
I own both products and can honestly say the HD Powder is the better choice. It does a better job with reducing oil, and has a smoother consistency. I would visit a store and sample both though, as this is only a personal opinion. Hope I could help!
answered 3 years, 10 months ago
nicclovessephora
(Long Island, New York)
answer 15
HD powder is definitely better, it keeps my skin matte ALL day (which is a miracle for me!) And the other kind only stays matte for the morning. highly recommend the HD powder
answered 3 years, 10 months ago
answer 16
I have both as well. I remember in the BE instructional video where they say you can apply the mineral veil powder very liberally - well that is because you have to. I always ran out of that stuff first. The HD powder gives that same softened matte look with less product (in fact, I wouldn't overdo it) and in much less time. I don't have to buff much, just put it on and go. I also feel that this smooths on better so I don't look over-powdered.
answer 17
I used MV for years and was very happy with it- that is until I tried HD microfinish. I cannot speak to shine control, as i do not have oily skin. But I can say that HD gives my face an extra smooth finish, silky, and flawles. I still have a TON of MV left and use it on days when I don't care about looking my best- cause I dont want to throw it out.
answered 4 years, 2 months ago
answer 18
I have both products and actually used the HD Microfinish Powder the most. I feel it soaks up any shine. I usually don't put it on right after my make-up application, but wait a little. My bare minerals always tends to add a shine to my face throughout the day/night. I wish they had a pordable one of these! Sometimes I still do see shine later in the night after using this product so I usually just blot with a tissue or toilet paper.
answered 4 years, 7 months ago
answer 19
HD without hesitation. i have used both and threw the mineral stuff out. the HD is much better quality and works brilliantly. nothing about bare minerals is brilliant for me.
answered 4 years, 7 months ago
nawtypoptart
(providence, RI)