I have fair skin and green eyes. I like Gabby. It is a light plum with lots of pink undertones. It is not a dark color. I have turned many of my friends of all skin types on to this color. They are addicted to buxom and Gabby is their favorite color.
Since "Claire" is a mauve color in the diamond finish, I'm guessing you'd like something shimmery. I think peach, coral, and pinkish rose shades would look great on someone with your coloring. I recommend the shades "Amber" (shimmering soft peach), "Destiny" (shimmery peach nectar), "Debbie" (coral pink shimmer) and "Leslie" (gilded pearl pinkish rose.) I hope this helps you! :)
Since you are currently wearing a mauve color, if you want to go a little darker, but still sheer, I just bought "STARR" and absolutely love it. It's a diamond raspberry color. But, I also have brown hair and love peach colors. I also have "AMBER" which has some sparkle, but not as much as the diamond. Amber is a soft shimmering peach. And I like the "CELESTE" which is a diamond sparkle in a glimmering soft peach.
Being some what the same coloring, I think you'd like these colors!
Hope this helps!
Honestly, with Buxom Lips, I really don't think you could go wrong with ANY color!!! :)