I, too, used Weather All from Bare Essentials until it was discontinued. I tried another product, but that didn't work well. Then a Sephora customer consultant told me about Aqua Seal. Love it! It works for me when I sweat during my high intensity workouts!
I'm sorry that I'm not familiar with that comparison product, but can give you extensive info on the Make Up Forever Eye Seal. Here's what I wrote in my review. I hope that you find it helpful:
I'm 43 and have had a love affair with makeup since my early teens. In all of those years, I have never come across such an awesome product! I work long hours and my eye makeup will stay on until you take it off. No kidding. It even beats watery allergy-eyes!
At first I was hesitant to get so little product at the price, but I read a review that told of how little you need to use and it's true! The bottles lasts me forever since I use just about 2 drops a day. (I'm on my 2nd bottle at this point)
Now, I've gotta admit that at first I used it wrong and ruined some awesome eye shadows. DON'T put it on your brush and then dip into your shadow. The shadow will harden like a rock, as will your brushes (although you can clean those).
Put a drop or 2 on the back of your hand, then using your finger, spread it all over your eyelids and wait for it to get tacky, at least. Probably 60-90 seconds. You can then apply your eye makeup as normal (I use a brush); your shadow will maintain its consistency and your brushes will just need normal cleaning. (if the seal comes off onto your brush, you haven't waited long enough.)
That's it!!! Enjoy your - now waterproof - eye makeup for 10-12 hours or longer. It is a real miracle product - and I don't say that easily!
answered 1 year, 8 months ago