to me it has a subtle floral, minty scent. i noticed the mint first.

This does actually smell like minty rose...it's an interesting combination. It is not overly minty though, I find the mint aspect to be very light and the main scent is rose.

it smells like mint!!!great!!

Actually smells like roses!

It actually smells like minty roses. It's great.

It smells like minty roses, just like you would think.

it smells like roses. with a soft hint of mint.

It smells like roses and peppermint

Hi,

It smells mostly mint, with perhaps a tiny bit of rose. The mint smells great and refreshing, but it's not a sharp mint smell, because it's softened by the rose.

Hope this helps.

exactally like a minted rose would smell! lol
its not overpowering mint though. Its actually a really soft smell

This is very very sheer. Only the tiniest hint of pink on the lips even though the color is deeper in the pan.

The color is very sheer, mostly just a little bit shiny like vaseline would be.

it gives you a light red touch to your lips

Very sheer.

Very sheer-basically colorless

It's sheer. If you're looking for a hint of color, get the Burt's Bees lip color sticks.

Hi,

It's a very sheer, barely there color... It sounds like it would be perfect for your needs.

Hope this helps.

Sheer with a slightly reddish tint when on the lips.

It just has the barest hint of colour and a nice shine. You won't really appear to be wearing anything outside of a clear gloss.

barely any- just enough to look refreshed

The Minted Rose makes your lips tingle a little because of the mint, and the tint is a bit darker. I find the glossiness of it different than the original. It seems less thick, while still providing enough moisture and a glossy finish. Personally, I like this one better than the original!

its more red and it smells like mint

Both list the same ingredients, and the only difference I notice is the scent and flavor.

This product has mint in it so there is a slight tingling sensation- which i happen to love.

The texture feels the same and it has about the same amount of shine and feel on your lips. I think it is exactly the same except for the mint. The color does not show on lips.

Yes! The minty hint is better!

No.

Yes, it is different in that it has a peppermint base. So, it your lips are chapped, or skin is sensitive, it relieves the burn, softens. But like the original it's thick, so a little bit goes a long way. Use sparingly.

Hi,

They seems the same to me, except for the color and the scent. All are equally as good as far as I'm concerned.

Hope this helps.

Minted Rose Lip Balm is made with mint (it plums lips & give a Fresh effect)

yes - the mint does plump the lips a bit...

no, but it's gives you a fresh feeling

No plumping action or mint taste at all.

I didn't notice any extra volume. But I don't really look for that in a lip balm.

This product will not plump your lips. It will sooth dry lips if you have a problem with that.

I definitely think it does. The menthol plumps and also serves to redden the skin of the lips...love this stuff.

No, it does not "plump" the lips.

not at all it just makes your lips smell wonderful but it has no plumping pluss it doesnt really stay on and it doesnt help with dryness

no it doesn't, it just moisturizes.

Hi,

This is a balm and not a plumper. However, it does hydrate lips well, so fine lines won't be as obvious.

Hope this helps.

yes this is a good one but it doesn't give much color to my lips its really nice

Okay, so from Sephora you can get Smith's Minted Rose Rosebud Salve or in flavours Original or Strawberry. They add a little bit of shine, shimmer, relieve pains, prevent chapped lips or cracking lips, gloss and it's good for not only lips but if you have burns or dry elbows or knees then you can apply a bit there too. It helps and soothes basically everywhere. The only thing it doesn't have that you want a bit of is it doesn't add a bit of colour. It adds maybe a drop or a touch but not anything extremely noticable. I hope that doesn't change anything! You can buy it online or at Sephora stores too. It's just great :). Hope this helps!

This balm is probably the best in this line. Very moisturizing. Great under lipstick or alone.

I'm not sure if its the best lip balm from rosebud because this is my first time trying these products. However, i read that the salve lipbalm is really good. I'm going to purchase the can that comes with all three lip balms soon :]

This is definately my favorite! I love minty lip products :)

Yes, ma'am! This is your balm! It smells awesome; the mint gives your lips a little tingle but the rose keeps it from being too potent. It will make your lips shiny but not goopy, and give you a natural rosy-red colour (like the colour of your lips, only better). It softens and last a long time. Do it up, this is the best gloss ever!

Try this lip balm. I'm pretty pleased with it. The minty scent is refreshing without being overpowering and it kept my lips moist and soft. Also, my lips didn't dry out after it wore off.

It won't leave you with white goop on your lips. You'll love it.

This product definitely has all the qualities you are looking for. Lightweight, non-waxy, slightly tinted, long-lasting. Also, for $7, it is quite a lot of product for the money. It works perfectly as a casual gloss for everyday activities.

This product gives you a lot of moisture and does work very well, but the moisture does not last long.

I found the rosebud salve in my local sephora store.

In my experience, Sephora restocks lip products fairly quickly. I received my last "Back In Stock" notice within a week of requesting it.

Its in stock now :]

Its in stock now, but I am returning the two I just got today (12/15/2010) they are not worth it, and dried my lips more than they were.

i found the minted rose lip balm and strawberry while waiting on line to be checked out. look in the bins where they have the travel size products

I LOVE the minted rose. The rose is too rosy for me, and the strawberry smells too fake strawberry if that makes sense. I love strawberry usually, but it smelled too fake for me. Maybe that was just the tester, but I love love love the minted rose.

I have only tried the Rosebud, but honestly after using it, I can confidently say to look no further.

Rosebud, it is cheap and it works wonderfully. I use mine daily. And great scent.