It's not as sparkly or intense at most UD, but holds up well all day, worth the $
answered 3 years, 4 months ago
This shadow is talc free if that's a concern of yours for sensitive skin or for avoiding possible harmful ingredients. I don't use those other brands generally but this one looks great! It's long lasting and richly pigmented.
answered 4 years, 8 months ago
In my experience, Urban Decay deluxe shadows look bold in the tin and sheer on my lids. It also travels despite the awesome power of Too Faced Shadow Insurance. I have Urban Decay deluxe shadow in Graffiti and Shady Lady in Shameless Shana.
answered 4 years, 9 months ago
I have tons of shadows from Stila and Urban Decay but recently have fallen in love with TheBalm! Stila's eyeshadows are very hit or miss. Kitten is one of my fav colors but many of their shadows barely show up and are very muted. Urban Decay is great but I'd have to say I'm really loving TheBalm!! The shadows are highly pigmented, long lasting and I feel like the colors are more wearable.
answered 4 years, 10 months ago
(Orange County, CA)
I'm totally in love with urban decay!!! Love, love, love the naked palette; and I have mowie wowie, urban cowboy rides again, and a few others. I have a few from stila (kitten and wheat) and a huge color palette they had at Costco at Christmas. Urban decay is the best because it has a lot of colors and intensities of glitter and shimmer, and matte.
Wow - thanks for the answers! Since I asked it a while ago, I have now had the chance to try all 3 and yes, Shady Lady is the bomb! I do think UD ranks up there, but I'm not a big Stila fan - maybe I got a bad palette (the Red Carpet palette). Of the three, Shady Lady seems to have more pigmentation and staying power... I'm happy w/ the choice! Thanks again, answer-ers!!!
Shady lady stays on longer & wears better! the colors are awesome
answered 5 years ago
ShadyLady shadows are the best shadows I have ever tried hands down! I have tried every shadow in every price point and this one wins the #1 spot. I would pay $30 for these, they are that good.......really!
answered 5 years, 2 months ago