This pencil is not good for a tightline. It isn't very precise and always needs sharpening.
I use this product for tightlining and have not had any problems. Easy application, and unlike other eyeliners where you can hardly tell you applied eyeliner, the liner is noticeable. Doesn't seem to wear off throughout the day and my very sensitive eyes have never had a problem tightlinining with this liner.
The one problem I have had is that, yes, sometimes (usually only if I'm a bit sloppy or heavy handed with the liner while tightlining my upper eyelid), the product will transfer to my bottom eyelid, but only faintly, and only rarely.
answered 6 months ago
HOURGLASS-1.5MM Mechanical Gel Eye Liner is AMAZING. Its so easy to use, its long-lasting, and doesn't transfer in to the bottom lid.
answered 7 months ago
(Toronto, ON, CA)