What it is: An industrial-strength concealer. What it does: This award-winning concealer camouflages dark circles, shadows, and discoloration without creasing or fading. An added bonus? This formula is now available in a full range of shades from light to deep so gals of all skintones can be imperfection-free.

Questions & Answers:

71 Questions

441 Answers

Ask a New Question

Overall Rating:

4.3

out of

Read All 3457 Reviews3457

Questions & Answers for Benefit Cosmetics Boi-ing

Question

Which shade of Boi-ing?

I use Fairly Light Matte from BE.. which shade of Boi-ing should I get?

asked 2 years, 4 months ago

missrx

on Boi-ing

9 answers

Answers

answer 1

Buy 01 and 02 and then mix to create a custom shade. I have also experienced the reverse raccoon look with 01, but 02 can look a bit too dark...gotta use both.

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

mdows37

answer 2

1 or 2

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

aschultz

(San Diego, CA)

answer 3

Get shade 01

answered 2 years, 1 month ago

beebrunet

(Alberta,Canada)

answer 4

I use Fairly Light too, and I use Boi-ing in 02 Medium. I tried the 01 Light and exchanged it.... it gave me that "reverse raccoon" look.

Hope that helps you!

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

valfromtexas

(Fort Worth, TX)

answer 5

I use 01, am blonde and would be considered "fair" for most cosmetics. I know it says to pick 02 if you're in doubt, but I like the lighter look on me. I use Estee Lauder double wear light in shade 02 if that helps.

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

beamerjo

(Billings, MT)

answer 6

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

secon

(Pittsford, NY)

answer 7

i am pretty fair with freckles, and boi~ing #1 was a little too light for me, #2 a little too dark so i have both and mix with my finger in the pot before applying

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

amy73

(Marietta, GA)

answer 8

I use medium from BE and the medium boi-ing. You would probably like the lighter one better.

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

yopo

(Columbus, OH)

answer 9

the light shade!

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

mmmmolly

Question

does it need powder to set?

In the past I have used a creamier concealer,but love the coverage of this.It does seem a little drier.Do I need to set with powder to keep it form creasing or coming off?i am worried about powder emphasing lines/dryness.

asked 2 years, 4 months ago

Anonymous

(cincinatti ,OH)

on Boi-ing

9 answers

Answers

answer 1

not really

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

aschultz

(San Diego, CA)

answer 2

No, it doesn't need a powder on top :)

answered 2 years, 1 month ago

beebrunet

(Alberta,Canada)

answer 3

I have to agree with some of the other answers. I use Bare Minerals and I just use their concealer brush dusted with Bare Minerals to set the concealer. It works like a charm =)

answered 2 years, 1 month ago

dinorahinsa

(San Antonio, TX)

answer 4

II never used powder to set this stuff, and I'm in TX with crazy humidity. So you'll probably be okay with just the Boi-ing! :)

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

valfromtexas

(Fort Worth, TX)

answer 5

I lightly dust my face w/a mineral powder and the concealer lasts all thru my work day without any color change, or caking/drying affect.

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

kge1

(Lakewood, OH)

answer 6

I would say you don't have to use a powder to set. I've tried several concealers lately (Laura Mercier, Bobbi Brown, Dior, The Balm, and some drug store brands). This one has the best finish, meaning it is more velvety and matte. It doesn't leave a shine behind whatsoever. However I don't find it drying at all. I have atopic dermatitis (eczema), and my skin gets super dry. You probably don't want to put it directly under your lower lash line (I mean DIRECTLY under it) it will crease just a bit, but it's honestly not as bad as the others.

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

organicgal

(SLC, UT)

answer 7

I set my Boi-ing with a very light dusting of powder, it seems to keep it from creasing. I don't think anything out there is completely crease proof, so I touch mine up at lunch and dinner with a tiny bit of powder.

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

beamerjo

(Billings, MT)

answer 8

yes use powder, especially around eye area

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

secon

(Pittsford, NY)

answer 9

A teeny bit of superfine powder can help set real trouble spots where you might layer concealer with powder, but otherwise, this does not need powder to set.

answered 2 years, 4 months ago

hollisb

(Ellicott City, MD)

Question

Im in between light and medium, sooo which one?

i dont want to look to dark or too light, is medium ligh-ish at all or acually medium?

asked 2 years ago

Anonymous

(Oregon)

on Boi-ing

9 answers

Answers

answer 1

I say go with the 2 unless you are really fair. The 1 is too light for me and the 3 is pretty dark.

answered 6 months ago

flower99

(Pekin, IL)

answer 2

I have semi-light skin and accidentally chose the Light 01. Way too light for dark circle use! Medium ended up being just perfect and if you need it slightly lighter, you can set with a lighter powder if need be.

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

sykosgirl

(Overland Park, KS)

answer 3

I am too. I got 2, my mother got 3 ...tough one, it is awesome though

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

aschultz

(San Diego, CA)

answer 4

I'm in between 01 Light and 02 Medium, so I just mix them together to get the perfect shade.

answered 1 year, 11 months ago

clovisorange

(Houston, TX)

answer 5

Medium is definitely too dark for me, which is too bad because medium is in all the combokits!

answered 1 year, 11 months ago

moduslotus

(Boston, MA)

answer 6

In my opinion it is very much a medium. It might be easier to blend a slightly lighter Light with your skin tone than tone down a Medium that is too dark, depends on your concealer needs though! If you need to brighten then go lighter.

answered 2 years ago

mmmore

(PHX, AZ)

answer 7

The light is really light!

answered 2 years ago

crlincoln

(Astoria,OR)

answer 8

Medium is perfect. It's kind of an "everyone" color. I'm super pale, but medium works great. It does not come out on the skin as orangey/dark as it looks. Light may make imperfections look worse. Definitely go for the medium.

answered 2 years ago

eyeshadowhor

(Alabama)

answer 9

I have a pretty light complexion and surprisingly enough Medium is the perfect shade for me. Light looked white against my skin.

answered 2 years ago

murphy01

(Knoxville, TN)

Question

Is this product good for covering under eye bags?

asked 1 year ago

Anonymous

(Boston, MA)

on Boi-ing

9 answers

Answers

answer 1

Oh boy is it!! Its THE best I have ever found. I have searched all the best brands and NOTHING compares to this. I came out of the womb with terrible dark circles, i've been asked multiple times (before finding this product) how I 'got those black eyes?' I am in love and use it everyday. It covers exceptionally well. A little goes a long way. (plus the little pot lasts a long time!)

answered 3 weeks ago

OliviaKGrace

(Marion, IL)

answer 2

No, you should get a liquid or cream.

answered 6 months ago

corinnemt

(Homer City, PA)

answer 3

I would say it does. I have circles under my eyes and it helps quite a bit!

answered 8 months ago

redwingsnut

(Portland, OR)

answer 4

As much as I LOVE this product, I'd say is more for the darkness than it is for the actual bags. Erase paste seems to help a little more with the 'bag' issue. I was using the Boing on the pic if that helps any.

Images for this Answer

(click to see full-size image)

answered 9 months ago

marie921

(Orlando, FL)

answer 5

It is for mild circles, but it doesn't color-correct. So, if you have dark circles, I would put a color corrected primer on first and then layer the concealer over.

answered 9 months ago

jessicaceleste

(Boston, MA)

answer 6

Yes covers very well you won't even know they existed when you put it on!

answered 9 months ago

Katiebug8898

(California)

answer 7

It doesn't cover them very well. I would recommend Eye Bright!

answered 9 months ago

Vivalavalla

(Long Island, NY)

answer 8

It's relatively good at covering dark circles, not bags. For circles, you can still tell they're there, they are just the color of the concealer. This concealer tends to fade though, so you have to reapply it throughout the day. I suggest trying it on at the store.

answered 10 months ago

audreyclaire

(San Francisco, CA)

answer 9

I don't think any concealer will cover bags, but if you mean dark circles/areas under the eyes, then YES! It's really, really good for that.

answered 11 months ago

spokanegirl

Question

boi-ing vs. erase paste

I've been reading reviews and I can't decide which is better for covering dark circles and blemishes- Benefit Erase Paste or Benefit Boi-ing? The products seem to do the same thing, so what's the difference?

asked 2 years, 6 months ago

Anonymous

(San Antonio, TX)

on Boi-ing

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

Boing definatly! Erase paste is ONLY for undereyes. If you use erase paste on face, you'll look orange :)

answered 2 years, 1 month ago

beebrunet

(Alberta,Canada)

answer 2

I have put my erase paste away and use BOI-ING exclusively.

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

kge1

(Lakewood, OH)

answer 3

I have used both products. Erase Paste is not as heavy duty as the Boi-ing. It is lighter feeling as well. But the Boi-ing covers dark circles wonderfully.

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

lloydmb

(Moncton, NB, Canada)

answer 4

erase paste is much better at coverage and goes on much smoother

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

pughster

(Tulsa, OK)

answer 5

I don't own Erase Paste (I wish I did!) but I have sampled it in store. I would say that Boing is better for undereye where you don't want something super wet or creamy that might cause transfer of your eye makeup and smudging. However, I don't find it to be that great for blemishes. If you have larger ares to cover it's good but for spot covering, it's difficult to blend and use since it works best when warmed in between your fingers. I would go with Erase Paste if you're mostly concerned about blemishes since it seems like that would work well with a brush.

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

ashory08

(PA)

answer 6

I've tried both. Erase paste is VERY creamy. It isn't good for blemishes at all, I think it would just make it worse. Boing is very good for blemishes. As far as for dark circles, they are both mediocre with boing being a little bit better, but it creases a lot.

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

mila22

(Philadelphia. PA)

answer 7

Boing is cheaper, obviously, so it has less coverage than Erase Paste. It goes on for a more natural look, as if your blemishes/dark circles have slightly diminished. Erase paste works with heavy coverage to create a flawless look that is less natural than it's cheaper counterpart.

answered 2 years, 5 months ago

katgaze

(San Francisco, CA)

answer 8

I've used both boi-ing and erase paste in the situations you described. Although I like both products, I'll go to boi-ing over erase paste simply because I've found boi-ing to laste with high quality longer then erase paste.

answered 2 years, 6 months ago

frankiestein

(Seattle, WA)

Question

Boi-ing concealer: is it good for oily/acne prone skin?

Would like to buy a good concealer, im thinking about this but im not sure if it's good for my type of skin. Has anyone tried it?

asked 1 year, 5 months ago

annacuevashh

(CA)

on Boi-ing

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

I loved this concealer until it started to give me horrible breakouts. I wouldnt recommend this if you have oily skin. My new favorite is smooth operator by Tarte. It has natural looking full coverage but it's all natural and hasn't made me breakout once!

answered 8 months ago

Miss360

(Hudson Valley, NY)

answer 2

I was using the Erase Paste and my skin broke out plus it did not stay on, and was greasy so I tried the Boiing and my skin is just fine and I have very sensitive skin and so far I have no break-outs!! If you are in doubt I have found that if you put a tiny dab just under your ear on your neck and let it there for 24 hours you should have your answer...if you aren't going to have a problem you will know...it is one of the spots where the skin is very thin and it will have a reaction that way you wont have it all over your face!

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

vtpj

(Knoxville, Tennessee)

answer 3

Yes! I have very oily skin. Since I've been using Boi-ing, I have actually noticed a decrease in my face becoming shiny throughout the day. I'm telling you this stuff is awesome!

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

hmilner17

(Milwaukee, WI)

answer 4

I would say no, because this is very ceamy. The consistency is better for dry skin. I would say to try something oil free and powder based.

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

caitlinashley

(Watertown, CT)

answer 5

I have oily skin and have never had a problem with Boi-ing. I love it!!! One rule that I stick to now that I constantly used to break was the "wash your makeup off before bed". Makes a huge difference. I have dark circles under my eyes from allergies & sometimes a lack of sleep. This concealer does the trick!

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

sykosgirl

(Overland Park, KS)

answer 6

I think if you have oily or acne-prone skin you would really enjoy this product because it is very thick and not oily like other concealers.

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

bubblybelle

(Fayetteville, AR)

answer 7

I would definitely avoid this if you have oily, acne-prone skin. I had high hopes for this concealer on my blemishes and under-eye circles, but then I read the ingredients list, and it contains both petrolatum and mineral oil. Not only are these cheap and low-quality ingredients, they make me break out like crazy. I didn't risk even trying it out, it went straight back to the store. I don't think I'll shop Benefit again if dressing up cheap ingredients in a pretty pot is their bag.

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

tforall

answer 8

No. It is not good for acne-prone skin. It clogs my pore everytime I use it. (gets whiteheads on the spot i use this concealer). It gives good coverage though.

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

renchu

(Albany, NY)

Question

How does this Boi-ing compare to Erase Paste specifically in regards to creasing?

I have been using Erase Paste mainly for under-eye circles (in addition to the occasional blemish or dark spot) for close to a year now. It works wonderfully at concealing everything, however, specifically under my eyes, it tends to crease A LOT. Setting with powder just makes it feel cakey on my dry, sensitive skin and using it in conjunction with Stay Don't Stray doesn't seem to help either. It has gotten to the point where I just use a thinner application of it to prevent the creasing but it does not cover as well and it stil wears off as the day goes on. I was in Sephora the other day, noticed Boi-ing and wondered if it could be the answer to my problems. Does Boi-ing cover as well or better than Erase Paste, will it crease as Erase Paste does, and how will it affect dry skin?

asked 1 year, 3 months ago

d5quared

(New Rochelle, NY)

on Boi-ing

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

I've used both and I don't have the creasing problem with Boing.

answered 9 months ago

marie921

(Orlando, FL)

answer 2

This is a good concealer but as for how it compares to Erase Paste....I can not get either one to "not" crease. They both cover well but they just don't stay on and they do crease. I find them WAY to drying to wear under the eyes...it makes wrinkles...it draws up the skin as it's dries up under the eyes so I keep it as far away from my eyes as possible. It is the only product that I have found that will cover spider veins...it just does not last or stay on for very long...some times I have to re-touch before I even leave the house ...just after putting it on...but it is better than the dozens of others I have tried. I just wish I could find a concealer that will stay on for the day or even a few hours!!

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

vtpj

(Knoxville, Tennessee)

answer 3

Both cover well, but I use erase paste primarily for the under eye area as it's a bit easier to spread and less drying. I use boi-ing strictly for spot concealing (and it works wonders) and erase paste for the under eye area.

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

lianam

(Boston, MA)

answer 4

What kind of eye cream are you wearing? You'll want to use one like Origins Plantscription Eye Treatment, which has the texture of a gel and absorbs instantly, before you apply the Erase Paste or Boing. Either way, Boing should definitely not crease or smudge.

answered 1 year, 2 months ago

alesia1

(Sacramento, CA)

answer 5

Boin-ing creases a little if it's applied to heavily or not blended in enough. However, since I've never use Erase Paste so I can't compare the two.

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

katberry

(San Jose, CA)

answer 6

Erase paste seems creamier than boi-ing . I too have dry skin and didn't like the way boi-ing set under the eyes. Using a rich cream first made it crease. I would try another brand.

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

jessluv

(San Jose, CA)

answer 7

I have used this and no problems even all day wear. I have not used the ease paste though. I bought this for under eye consealer, but I do work on everything I have found out. I do no wear foundation and even my husband could notice that I had it on under eyes and covering belmishes. It is very easy to work with. Sometimes I will apply smooth operator by tarte over it just to set if I'm going to have a long day. Smooth operator by tarte is also a wonderful product would take a look at that too. I do really like this consealer though, I been using it for about a month now and not even a dent it still looks brand new.

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

deasy

(Boston MA)

answer 8

I bought Erase Paste and didn't like the fact that it would creep into my creases. I bought boi ing and it works so much better. It stayed in place. I have combination skin, so I don't know how it would affect yours.

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

elise12

(Lafayette, LA)

Question

Does Boi-ing Concealer cover dark melasma

I am medium/tan and need a good concealer to cover melasm from pregnancy and hormones.

asked 2 years, 4 months ago

Anonymous

(Lewes, DE)

on Boi-ing

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

I bet it would be great for that. It covers all my discoloration due to age spots and surgery and redness.

answered 1 year, 5 months ago

aschultz

(San Diego, CA)

answer 2

YES! It covers EVERYTHING! :)

answered 2 years, 1 month ago

beebrunet

(Alberta,Canada)

answer 3

I get it too, from being in the sun, and hormones. It's like a mustache but there's no hair! I feel your pain!!! Boi-ing is pretty good for that. I'd wait till it's at its worst and duck into a Sephora to try it first.... but their return policy is great so either way. Might as well try it and see. Good luck! (Oh and if you're undecided between 2 shades, I'd go for the darker one. Then you don't get the "reverse mask" look.)

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

valfromtexas

(Fort Worth, TX)

answer 4

I believe this can cover anything on your face. just dont use it under your eyes. i have dark acne scaring and it covers them with ease. just moisturize your face very well and apply with confidence.

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

shobiklobik

(Merced, CA)

answer 5

If used in conjunction with the right products, yes. Try using it together with Lemon Aid or Erase Paste, although I suggest the Erase Paste over the other. What I do is use the Erase Paste first when applying all make up and then use Boi-ing to even out the color (if needed) or throughout the day for touch ups. Both products work very well together and when used alone. Hope this helps!

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

krizia422

(Virginia Beach)

answer 6

I personally think it is probably the best coverage I've found that doesn't leave big creases under your eyes. I use it to cover dark circles and put a light dusting of powder over it when I'm done. It is definitely better coverage than most concealers I've tried. Hope that helps.

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

beamerjo

(Billings, MT)

answer 7

YES! I have had a bout with melasm after a pill switch, I am fair but this is the best concealer i have used to hide and correct.

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

secon

(Pittsford, NY)

answer 8

This is the best concealer on the market. It will leave your skin flawless looking!

answered 2 years, 3 months ago

terridougherty

(Warren, IN)

Question

Does this product cover up freckles?

I have freckles on my face and i absolutely hate them. I would like to find the right foundation/concealer product that will cover them up.

asked 1 year, 4 months ago

isabelh

(Scottsdale, Arizona)

on Boi-ing

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

Yes, it absolutely covers freckles. I have fair skin and a smattering of freckles, this concealer evens my tone across the board.

answered 9 months ago

MagSoho

(New York, NY)

answer 2

I have sun spots (not the same as freckles but very similar in the annoying area) and it seems to do the job of covering them up very well. You can't tell I have freckles when I have Boing on

Images for this Answer

(click to see full-size image)

answered 9 months ago

marie921

(Orlando, FL)

answer 3

It will most likely cover up your freckles but you would have to use it all over your face...if you have them all over and that ...at least to me...would be very heavy! I only use it in the spots where I need it and I do have to carry the product with me so I can do touch-ups...it doesn't stay on my for very long at all but I do like it because it's the only concealer that covers my broken capillaries!! Have you tried any sort of a "fade cream" for your freckles? I am not sure what they are called but you need to see a Dermatologist to get a good one...they will get rid of your freckles all together...if you want to spend that kind of money!

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

vtpj

(Knoxville, Tennessee)

answer 4

Yes. I have freckles too and I was so happy when it covered it up.

answered 1 year, 3 months ago

katiannlee

answer 5

I have a lot of freckles also and it works really well to cover them up. You may have a couple freckles noticeable but nothing to bad.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

taylorbt

answer 6

Yes, if you apply it in multiple layers. As for a large area of your face, there is an product called Oxygenetix. It is a base for people to use to conceal facial injuries or after having facial dermabrasion. My dermatologist recommended it for me after I had some precancerous spots removed.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

warriorwife

(Longwood, Florida)

answer 7

I think it would cover up freckles. I have several small freckles, moles, and post acne scars that i use the concealer on and it works well on me.

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

sokhacola

answer 8

If Benefit Boi-ing concealer can hide the very dark burn marks that I had on my face, I know that it can easily tackle freckles. This is by far the best concealer that I have ever used. This is one step above a regular concealer. The other concealer that I use is Smashbox and that one is more for every day use. Boi-ing is for hiding more serious problem areas. And, it lays well underneath your makeup.

By the way, there is nothing wrong with freckles. You should embrace them. But if you want to have that flawless skin look from time to time, you can use this cover up. Trying to hide freckles forever will only leave you stressed out. Good luck!

answered 1 year, 4 months ago

atlchick

(Atlanta, GA)

Question

Is this concealer waterproof??

I like to wash my face in the afternoon cause it can get pretty hot and humid where I live, so whether my concealer is waterproof is very important to me.. also does it by any chance create a nice glowy effect under your eyes?

asked 11 months ago

Sephaholic

on Boi-ing

8 answers

Answers

answer 1

I usually find it doesn't come off super easy, with just facewash and water unless you really focus around your eyes (i use it as an under-eye concealer), in fact I would recommend a eye makeup remover. I have swam in it and been pretty impressed with how well it stayed. But Im not sure if you'd call it "waterproof" per-say. But it DEFINITELY gives that awesome highlight glowy effect. I usually end up using it as a highlighter too.

answered 3 weeks ago

OliviaKGrace

(Marion, IL)

answer 2

This is about as waterproof as I have found in a concealor. It survived 12-hour shifts in Afghanistan and all summer in my husbands boat!! If you have humidity problems in your area, use this concealor and set it with a translucent powder.

answered 5 months, 3 weeks ago

LadyLolo

(Des Moines, IA)

answer 3

Not waterproof and no it does not create a glow.

answered 7 months ago

ksam1

(Elk grove village)

answer 4

not waterproof. I'm a swimmer, and it comes off when I swim.

answered 9 months ago

kewi00

(Portland, OR.)

answer 5

Though I absolutely love this product, it doesn't have that highlighting effect you are talking about. For that, you might want to try the erase paste... also by Benefit.

answered 9 months ago

marie921

(Orlando, FL)

answer 6

I don't think it is waterproof. It does last longer if you apply primer underneath or powder on top.

answered 9 months ago

jessicaceleste

(Boston, MA)

answer 7

Yes it is! I went in the pool several times with mine this summer and it stayed on!

answered 9 months ago

Vivalavalla

(Long Island, NY)

answer 8

No this concealer is not water proof, but it is quite water resistance since I've cried before and it didn't melt off. Also, it doesn't created luminosity under your eyes because it is a matte finish.

However, try the Make Up Forever Full Coverage concealer, it is just as nicely pigmented as this, and it IS water proof since I play tennis out in 100+ weather everyday and it does NOT melt off !

answered 10 months ago

MissMelodyV

(Amarillo, TX)

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | ... 8 | ...next