Hi,

Both look good. Most people have more than one shade of blush or lipstick, so it's nice to have an option of more than one shade.

Hope this helps.

Posetint is my favorite. :)

From my experience definitely Benetint. Posietint is not a product I plan on buying again. First off Benetint provides a natural rosy flush which blends easily given that it is liquid. The Posietint is a little creamier and when applied to face, I could not spread and it looked like I had pink streaks on my face that did not come off with makeup remover. Needless to say, Posietint was not a good for me and probably many others.

Benetint, it's good for all skin tones. Posietint is harder to apply and won't stay on for as long as benetint.

I personally would use Benetint. While Posietint is nice too, I find the colour too light, it seems to fade faster and it doesn't go on as dark to begin with, so I find Benetint a better bet for more dramatic, longer lasting colour. I think the only time I would pick Posietint over Benetint is if I were wearing very little makeup and just wanted a slight blush to my cheeks and lips.

I would say Posietint. I have very fair skin too and find that Benefit is just a little too red. i haven't bought posietint, but I've tried it in the store and ir looks very cute and natural.

Both will look good, you just need to decide which flush you prefer. If you prefer a rosy flush go for benetint, if you want a pink, sweet looking flush go with poisietint.

Both Benetint and Posietint would look good on fair skin. I have fair skin and have tried both.

It depends on what color you're going for, but I prefer the benetint because it can look natural and beautiful.

Both look really great. It depends on the look you are going after...for fair skin the benetint adds an instant amount of color. But the posietint is most natural and definitely is made for a fairer skin tone.

I think they are very forgiving and you can control how much color you have. I think either would work fine for you. Maybe try them in a Sephora store first to get an idea which you really like best. Good Luck !!!

I have only tried benetint and I have very fair skin, it looked great and wasnt too much. Since it is sheer its hard to overdo it!

I like both, but I use benetint more. my skin is very fair and i have auburn hair.

Hey! I think that Posietint is best for fair skin. Especially while you soak up the last bit of summer, it would be a great way to get that pop of color into a neutral colored outfit. Obviously it won't last you very far into the fall and winter but a lot of my fairer friends tell me that their experience with benetint is that they've looked like they had a raspberry popsicle because of it's harsh contrast against them. Either way, they're both great no matter which you settle on!

I'd say if you are fair with lighter colored hair, I'd go with the posietint. However, if you have darker hair with fair skin, the benetint will look great on you!

Well, it depends on what you are going for. Posytint is softer, and a little more subtle. I like to use it when I am going for a more natural look. Benetint is darker but a bit more sheer - so you can get sort of a flush going which is very cute and sexy all at once.

I have very fair skin and find I use Posytint most often - but benetint is still a fave of mine.

I haven't used posietint, but I'm very pale and the benetint (the redder one) is absolutely beautiful and just the right amount of color for me. any lighter and i don't think it would have the same effect. hope this helps!

If you want a natural look, pinch your cheek to see your natural flush color. Then choose the shade that most closely matches that color. Actually I love them both, but Benetint is my best match.

I have only tried bene-tint and by using it under my foundation I feel that it still looks very natural even with my fair compelxion. I really love it!

I have fair/light skin and I prefer the Benetint, it's a little more natural looking for me than the Posietint.

I have only tried the bene tint, but I believe that this will look nice on all skin tones because you control how little or how much you want. It is very natural looking when you blend it into your skin.

both look great i have them and use them

I think benetint would be the better of the two for you to use.

I haven't tried Posietint yet. I am sure it looks great on fair skin. But I use Benetint all the time, and I am really fair, and it looks great on my lips. I don't know about cheeks, but it is pretty sheer, so if you just put a little bit and blend quickly, it should look fine on fair skin. I think the color is designed to be universally flattering.

I think both will look good. The benetint looks really dark, but it applies sheer - just put on a bit at a time.

I personally liked benetint better

I think both look good on fair skin! you can make it more dramatic the more you apply.

BOTH

I would say Poisietint would look slightly better than benetint, because it's a lighter color than Benetint.

As soon as I try PosieTint, I'll report back on how it does on pale skin.

I like Benetint a lot, but I'm willing to go down a notch on the color.

I put on my Hour Glass Veil primer, Cera Ve moisturizer, Dior Skin Nude Concealer, Bobbi Brown Cream Foundation, MUFE HD Powder, Laura Mercier Mineral Powder and then pat in the Benetint. I find that this way works for me but I have very fair skin and need for it to show up, where as I was afraid that if I applied it before everything else, it would be muted. It didn't effect the look of my make up, though. That was also after applying about 2 or 3 coats of it to build up the color. I put a few dots on and then pat it in instead of rubbing so that might be why it works for me.

In order, I use my moisturizer, a liquid foundation, light dusting of Bare Minerals powder, then Benetint. I've found that, even after using the Bare Minerals powder, the Benetint is easy to blend in, possibly because I've already put on my moisturizer and liquid foundation. I put little swipes of Benetint on my cheeks and blend them in pretty much right where I swipe. It hasn't messed up my powder foundation doing it that way, but again, I don't cake on the powder stuff much.

Before, if you apply the blush afterwards, I think it would mess up your makeup.

Hi,

It's actually recommended that it goes on before powders, since adding liquids to any powders can compromise the powders.

Hope this helps.

I usually apply it before my Bare Escentuals foundation, but I always found it too pale and then added a powder blush on top afterwards. I ran out of Benetint, but the next time I buy it I may try putting it on after my foundation to see if it is brighter. Hopefully it won't smear my foundation too much!

I really think it depends on the person. If you want your cheeks to be a little brighter, then I would apply it after foundation. However, if you want a more subdued color, apply it before foundation.

i would use it after face makeup. you may have to use a bit more if you wear cream.liquid foundation since it may take a bit to absorb, and less if you use powder. dust on a bit of powder after to set it. i love it more liek a li stain but that's my $0.02.

You should apply the foundation first in most cases of blush but since this is in a liquid form, I'd suggest applying your foundation all over except for the apples of your cheek and after applying benetint, slowly blend it in.

I would apply the tint before the powder because the powder will help blend in the blush expecially because its liquid. The powder smooths it out.

If your foundation is liquid- use it after. if you use bare minerals best results would be before the powder- but it is fine to use after too.

I use Bare Minerals foundation and I apply Benetint afterwards. I have never applied it beforehand, may give that a go though!

I would apply after foundation but before powder/finishing powder.

for powder i would agree that it should go on first, but i love putting benetint over foundation-- it makes it easier to blend and adds a nice sheen.

i have medium skin and brown hair. benetint

I would say Benetint is DEFINITELY more natural looking. Posietint has a slight shimmer to it, and seems more creamy, compared to the very translucent and matte Benetint. Also, when people blush naturally, it tends to be more red toned (benetint) rather than pink toned (posietint)

I haven't tried Posetint but Benetint looks very natural on me. I have very fair skin and dark hair with hazel eyes. I love it! It looks like a flush to the cheeks. I use about 2 to 3 applications to get the look I desire. It has a great buildable quality.

Benetint looks alot more natural.

I would go for benetint. It looks more natural on any skin tone.

I've tried both repeatedly. Posietint was a more familiar creamy texture, and extremely streaky/dotty on my face, how you first touched it onto your skin determined the dark areas. The color is peachy and very, very subtle. Benetint is a surprising thin liquid, like water, and has more natural looking undertones of pink (at least on my skin). It spreads more easily and does a great job layering darker depending on how much your clothes white out your skin that day. Now I only use the Posietint for a day I want an obviously "made up" fashion look with trendy colors like a coral or nude lip, for fun; the benetint is for everyday and classic dressing up days.

The Benefit Poppy-Pink is a perfect color for your complexion (as it is the same as my own, I am certain this is true). Very sheer, brightening, same color as when you pinch your cheeks.

I'd go for benetint! I have similar coloring and I've found that it looks very natural on me

for your complexion, I would go with Benetint. start with a small amount for a more natural appearance. when it comes to this stain less is more but it really goes a long way. the posetint, while a cute summer color comes out as a very pink, 'barbie doll' tone and may not naturally compliment your described features. when applying the benetint, one stroke of the brush to the apple of your cheek followed by a quick blend (you can use your finger or a sponge) and the same to the lips is all it takes to fulfill a natural flush. apply more for your desired effect.

I only use my middle finger when applying Benetint. I do have a bit of staining but after about two hand washes with soap, it's gone.

wash them

soap and water

Hand soap and H2O works just fine if you use it right away otherwise use a little eye make up remover.

I use a little bit of Vaseline or coconut oil. Put it on the pink finger tip, let it sit for a few seconds and then wipe off with with a wash cloth.

I use eye makeup remover.

Hi,

Soap and water seems to work just fine, but if I really have the dye on my fingers I might use a waterproof makeup remover that's made for tough makeup. Last suggestion would be a petroleum jelly which worked when I once spilled some and it really got into a couple of fingers.

Hope this helps.

Its annoying! But after i wash my hands (Really rub them) I use antibac (the normal one without odor and almost 90% alcohol) And it comes off :S

no, it's a stain, looks very natural.
in this video the girl is using benetint on her lips and it looks gorgeous and natural: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WdBs-xgR8Q0

no

Hi

This is not sticky at all. It dries quickly to a natural finish.

Hope this helps.

This stain is definitely not sticky at all and does not change the texture of one's lips to any degree. If your husband likes natural, and you want your husband to think you have a naturally hot color, this is the product for which you've been searching! Go to your nearest sephora--don't wait for shipping...it's too perfect to wait one more day! just remember to layer to add more pop for night!

This is the most sheer non-sticky product and your husband will not even know you are wearing it if you put it on correctly. It is the most natural look for cheeks and lips. Beautiful and sheer definitely non-sticky! You will be happy you purchased this dual worker. It will become your go to makeup tool.

It's not sticky at all, it's a stain that you can control by layering it. Never feels like "makeup".

It's basically like water: once it dries, you won't know it's there (except that the color remains)

The 'benetint' is definitely just tint... Very watery consistency, and dries quickly. Perfect for under chapstick (or whatever other moisturizing type lip stuff you can wear).

you should put the moisturizer first, then the foundation, then you should use some powder to fix everything, then the benetint and then put some powder again. i hope this help

I have used it for a long time in different ways, but the way I like best is to swipe/ dab on the hollows of your cheeks (as much as one dip in the bottle attains) under the cheekbone and closer to your ear than nose, then pat it toward the apples of your cheeks, tending toward the cheekbones but not too high. Do it quickly though because it dries fast and if you pat/ blend too much the color will just come off on your fingers. Hope this helps!

very easy with the little applicator brush

How do you apply Benetint? I went pretty close to the directions with excellent results, although I think I probably applied more to my cheeks. I swished it across one cheek, then spread it around with my finger(s) to make it look natural, as you would with any blush, . I did only one cheek at a time as this is a type of dye. One doesn't want it to set in place too long. I hope this helped. I simply love it!!

Hi there! I apply benetint using my clean fingers. I have tried several brushes, but FAIL. It would only literally stain your cheeks like red spots and won't blend well that much. So yes, fingers are the easiest tool to blend them on your cheeks for a natural blush! Hope this helps!:)

Here's what I do: I take the little brush, and make three or four quick lines across my cheeks on the "apple" (or roundest part) of the cheek, right at the cheekbone. Then with a makeup sponge, I blend them. There's no magic to using "lines." Some ladies will draw a circle, and I've seen makeup artists paint a small triangle. The key - as with the application of all makeup, is to place it where you want it, start with a small amount (and add more later, if you like), and BLEND, BLEND, BLEND! It's very easy to use.

you can either put 3 dots on your cheeks and blend them together quickly after application, or you can do a quick swipe on your lips and rub together like you would with a traditional lip stick/gloss.

Use the brush they give you, much as you would on a painting. I usually outline the outside of my bottom lip, then quickly fill in the center, and then do the same thing for the top. Make sure to go quickly, though, as it sets rather fast. For a lighter look, scrap some of the paint off of the brush into the bottle, and then after applied, dab it evenly with a tissue or a finger.

get pink.

I have dark blonde hair and hazel green eyes and prefer the rose. I do like a rosy cheek though, so if you'd like more subtle blush, the peach may be the way to go. Either way, the staying power and natural color are the best on the market!

Rose

I haven't tried the pink, but the rose isn't as dark as it looks in the bottle. It's very natural looking, even on my fair skin.

In my opinion, the pink isn't as much a tint as a tinted highlighter, and the rose works on most any skin tone and is much more natural looking. I recommend the rose. It is so pretty, natural looking, easy to apply and stays on for quite awhile.

I'm black haired and green eyed. I wanted something that looked natural. I use the lighter version and I adore it. Its not too pink and not too red. I haven't tried the red yet but there hasnt been a need either.

As long as you use just a tiny bit of the product you should get a nice natural look from the original Benetint. The red isn't really that strong as long as you don't layer it. I use about three tiny dots on my lips and then blend it in with my finger and it looks really natural. It helps if you use some lip balm first though because it will be easier to blend. I hope this helps!

Depending on your skin tone, which I assume is fair (?) both benetint and posietint will not give you a nude flush. Benetint is rosey while posietint is on the pink-ier side. Hope that helps!

no, $28

$28.00

No, it is still 28 bucks. I bought it a couple of days ago in store for that price.

I paid $28 last week, so you may have been ripped off. =(

Buying cosmetics online will almost always be cheaper because #1 you still pay shipping and handeling and #2 if you buy online the company will get more out of you one way or another like you might find something to go with it and they knock down two birds with a highly fashionable stone

Hi

I notice you have a Canadian address. The prices on the website are in US$.

Hope that helps.

I just paid 28!! :)

after the foundation, but i don't like to use it on cheeks, it looks too dark and unnatural.

keep appling until you get the color desired

For lips, I add a gloss over it and it works very well. For cheeks, I use a tinted moisturizer rather than foundation and then put the benetint on my cheeks. Makes for a nice, light summer look.

Use it after the foundation on cheeks. It lasts all day. but you'll need to use more than just the 3 drops they tell you to use. On lips, you'd want to apply under a gloss. But you will need to reapply every so often.

Hi,

Apply Benetint first and then a gloss or other product. If you try to apply Benetint after a gloss, it might not adhere evenly or at all.

Hope this helps.

I use this product on my lips BEFORE applying vaseline/gloss, but I use this product after i apply my foundation...cheeks are the last step when I use this...the color tends to stand out more that way.

In order to make this lip stain really stain your lips red simply apply it and then just throw on your favorite lip moisturizer. The combination is killer. In order to make this lip stain really stain your lips red simply apply it and then just throw on your favorite lip moisturizer. The combination is killer. It will keep your lips looking naturally flushed and pouty all day. In terms of using bene tint on your cheeks this is my rule. If you are using a liquid or cream foundation go ahead and apply the bene tint over the foundation. If you are using a powder apply the bene tint before the foundation. Hope this helps.

no, the coral is available too. The Cha Cha Tint.

yes

Yes those are the only two stains. I haven't tried the bronzey-pink. The red really isn't that dark, but I am not sure what your skin tone is. It comes out a little bit redder than my nautural color when I apply the gloss.

The rose-tint is really not very pink - more reddish - and it's very natural looking on. I was apprehensive since it looks very red in the bottle but it settles down quite nicely when you apply it. The "posy" color is definitely toward the color side - also very pretty but more of a summery shade on my skin (it looks better with a tan and my skin is naturally quite pale.)

Go to the store and try it. You might be surprised. It seems to adapt to more skin tones than you would think.

yes the pink isnt so bad, nut the rose is horrible

Yes. If you want another shade, maybe you should look for another product.