I have very oily skin and I found that this is excellent at removing everything. All I have to do is use toner afterward. There is not even anything on the cotton pad after using toner. I just use the toner for the acne medication in it. If you use a microfiber cloth, you will remove all traces of makeup or oil left after using the balm (which wont be much!). No additional cleanser needed.

I use an additional cleanser. I use the gentle cleansing liquid after, then the toner #1. It is great for makeup removal, though! Highly Highly recommend. :)

The label says you need to use a cleanser afterwards. This is okay, though, because it will dissolve makeup so thoroughly that you can always go on to the cleansing step quickly

I don't use an additional cleanser, this is the only one I use... sometimes i may use a face wipe. but this is great at getting the makeup off...

I use just this (rub it into dry skin) and then remove with warm wash cloth and rinse w/ warm water. My skin feels very clean but never dry or tight after.

You will definitely need another cleanser. Cleansers that can remove stubborn eye makeup are too much for the rest of the face. Use this just in areas it's needed and get a more subtle cleaner for gentle face cleaning.

Yes! Depending on what type of skin you have this is not a deep cleanser at all. Its really greasy works great at taking off mascara but not cleaning your face..

This is all you need. You might just want to gently wipe your face with a wash cloth in tepid water...easy on the scrubbing...that's all you need.

Sometimes I use another cleanser after the cleansing balm because it can leave a little bit of an oily residue if you use too much...but it does remove all of my excess dirt and makeup on its own if I don't use too much.

It just depends on how your face feels. I usually follow up with Shiseido White Lucent cleansing foam (my cleanser of choice). Depending on if you have acne prone skin, scars that need lightening, etc., you might want to follow up for the extra punch. If you don't have any of those needs, this might do it for you for the evening cleansing routine.

Yes, you will need an additional cleanser. This is just a makeup remover, removing the dirt and makeup from the surface of your skin. After using this, rinse it off, then wash your face as normal to remove dead skin cells and any leftover makeup.

I have combination to oily skin and although this product may seem oily when applying it, it does not leave your skin oily at all. Rinse off with warm water and apply your usual toner. My skin remained the same as when using my regular cleansing stuff.

I have combination skin and this product has works wonders, and has not lead to any new breakouts.

yes. i have combination skin and this works for me perfect.

yes... I'm combination and get slightly oily, i love this product

I am both oily and super sensitive and I have had no issues at all with this cleanser. I do remove it with a warm wash cloth and rinse w/ plenty of warm water. Most foaming cleansers irritate my skin, but many creamy or oily ones can cause break-outs, this one has worked for me on both counts!

I have combination skin ad use it every night. I would suggest applying the balm to dry skin, wiping off with a wet cloth, then washing face as usual.

I have combination/oily skin and I love this stuff. However, I do use my usual face wash right after I use this to remove excess oil.

Absolutely...I have dry combination skin BUT I can't use anything with oil or I breakout with rosacea-like bumps.....it's really great.

I have oily/combination skin, and I have not broken out with the use of this product. It's excellent.

I have combination-oily skin (depending on the season), and I love it for all seasons. When you first put it on, it feels quite slick, but that's just silicone, not oil. Rub it in all over to remove makeup, and rinse with water. When you rinse, you'll definitely notice that the slippery feeling disappears. The thing is, you have to rub it in your skin without wetting your face first, or else the product breaks down before it has a chance to work.

I prefer the balm over the liquid in the bottle. The big difference for me is the fact that the balm stays on your face and eyes long enough to really do the job, where the liquid evaporates and soaks into the cotton you're using. Plus, it rinses off clean afterwards. It's awesome :)

I would pick the balm because it works just as well for eye makeup! The other bottled one is strictly for eyes and lips. I find the balm does both jobs well ;) Differentiating it is only a marketing strategy to sell more different products catered to different areas of the face. Though some makeup removers don't actually work with all, but this balm does. So just buy the balm~

I got the "take the day off" eye makeup remover as a GWP. I wear Bobbi Brown cream eye shadow-that stuff does NOT come off with water unless you scrub it off. "take the day off" eye makeup remover, with one gentle swipe with a cotton pad, took off ALL the eye shadow and eyeliner. Because it's so watery, I wouldn't use it on my face. The "take the day off cleansing balm" is a thick buttery goo, that gently rubbed on the face takes off ALL makeup. Because it's buttery, I don't put it on my eye lids, I prefer the liquid stuff and cotton pad. My skin is dry, partly age, partly climate, and the cleansing balm takes so little rubbing or effort to remove all traces of makeup. If I had to choose between the 2, I'd get the cleansing balm because it works so great for cleaning my face-I've used Ponds cold cream in the past. But if your skin isn't dry and you already have a product that you use for washing your face you're happy with, just get the liquid eye makeup remover. The "take the day off" eye makeup remover is an eye makeup remover, the balm is more of a face cleaner but also removes eye makeup.

My opinion is that this balm is definitely creamier than the liquid product, which I also like. But for winter or for drier skins, I think this is preferable because, while it does rinse clean, it leaves your skin soft and smooth. The only caveat is that for using it as an eye makeup remover, you have to be careful not to get it in your eyes, as it will leave your vision blurry until it washes away eventually. The liquid doesn't seem to have that problem because it's not so oily.

The balm is easier to apply, since you don't need a cotton ball or pad to apply. A little goes a very long way and it is definitely what it advertises. Very silky. But I haven't tried to bottle, so I can only vouch for the balm!

The Cleansing Balm, which comes in the jar, is far better. It's not the same product as the lids, lashes and lips makeup remover, which isn't made to remove face makeup and sunscreen. CB removes everything, even eye makeup, though the product instructions do not state that it can be used with eye makeup.

The important thing about this specific make-up remover is that it's developed for ALL of your make-up, not just eyes and lips but for your entire face meaning your foundation. That said I would recommend this product above products that only target your eyes and lips.

I have both products. To me the liquid is just an eye make-up remover that you would use with a cotton pad, and could use to remove long wear lip stick also. You still have to wash your face, actually I feel like I need to wash the product off as well, and I find it a bit irritating to my sensitive skin. The balm is the only cleanser I use at night, you rub it onto your dry skin (including eye area) and it melts into a sort of oily consistency. I then wipe everything off with a warm wash cloth and then rinse. I have super sensitive and break out prone skin and I have had no problems at all. BTW, I use the redness reducing cleanser in the a.m. and this combo is working well for me!

That's really the biggest difference. One is a liquid that you put on a cotton ball and swipe across eyes, one is a balm that you put on your fingers. Both work in the same fashion, it's more about which is most convenient for your beauty routine.

I have used both and I like the balm the best. I found the lotion a little bit harsh for my skin. The balm is goes a long way and I think is also a better deal for your money. But, I don't use it to remove my eye make-up....

I have the same problems with oily make up removers not rinsing off. This is what I do.
1. I use a dime size amount of this make up remover - more if I'm wearing stubborn foundation.
2. I gently message my face with this remover until my whole face is caked in it.
3. whilst keeping my eyes shut I apply a generous amount of my foaming facial cleanser onto my palm and message it into my face, so that the cleanser mixes in with my make up remover.
4. Then rinse off with tepid water.
5. I then use my toner to remove any trace amounts of make up.

Hope this helps

I use it on tough/waterproof makeup before I actually wash my whole face. I've also just wiped it away with a very warm wet cloth when I was in a hurry, but I prefer to wash it away with my normal cleanser(clinique 3-step mild soap).

I have not had a problem at all with this product. You may try using a damp washcloth instead of just rinsing with water. I use Clinique toner afterwards to remove any trace left. I absolutely love this product.

Use a tissue to wipe the makeup and remover off then reapply and rewipe until it's all gone. I'd try the liquid version of Take the Day off, it's much better.

Are you using this on wet or dry skin? It should be used on dry skin. It wont work at all on wet skin.

i always start with my eyes, apply the remover, let it sit for a few minutes and wipe the product off with a warm wet cotton pad, then do the rest of my face the same way. atferwards im left with a clean face, not oily and no extra traces of makeup.--hope this helps.

Are you massaging the product into your skin? Try doing soft rubs in circular motion, don't just slap it on and rinse off. You need to let the cream work its wonders. Massage it into your skin, around the eyes (in your case over your eyes for removal of eye makeup), about 20 secs. Then rinse off with warm water. That should do the trick! BUT be sure to follow it with a cleanser to finish it off! Hope this helps!

I usually grab a blob from the jar rub it between my hands, then onto my dry face then add water and continue to rub it on my face so it forms a lather then rinse. Hope this helps.

I don't know about rinsing with water, I can't do that, too drying for me. I use a warm wash cloth and just wipe off the cleanser. It doesn't leave my face oily or dry and I've tried a toner afterwards- no residue left (at least for me).

Strange that it won't rinse away, because I have no problem with warm water completely emulsifying it and rinsing away cleanly. Even cool water works for me. Does the product seem to be fresh, or could it have been ruined in shipment? Maybe if you took it into Sephora or Clinique, they could tell if it was damaged in some way. The only suggestion I can think of is that maybe you should wipe off most of it with a tissue or cotton pad, and then rinse with warm water. Sorry I don't have any better ideas! It has worked great for me.

The container says rinse off. I use it to loosen/remove eye makeup before I actually wash my whole face.

I've wiped it away with a damp cloth successfully, but just a tissue isn't enough for me. If you have a Clinique counter or sephora locally, I'm sure you could test it in-store.

You have to wash it off with water.

I usually rinse off but have used a damp wash cloth.

Tissues off or do as I do and use a wet washcloth. The cloth serves as an exfoliate.

You don't need water, it can be wiped off of skin easily.

I have used a tissue to wipe it off some of the time and it works quite well. I then use my normal cleanser to wash my face and that gets any residue off that the tissue didn't.

Slight wet the tissue with water and wipe the area off. That's how I use it when I don't want to wet my entire face or in a hurry. It works great!

I always wash this off with water. If you were in a bind, I suppose it would come off with a tissue as well.

Both. I prefer to rinse with water and it is still non-drying.

You could tissue off, but I would get the pump one instead if you want to do that. This one feels like it needs to be rinsed off, in my opinion.

The product does state that it can be used to remove sunscreen as well as makeup. It is gentle enough and rinses so cleanly that I would use it myself as a facial cleanser , if I wanted. Honestly, the jar is so large and you only require such a small amount to clean your eyes. It leads me to think that they intended people to use it on their face and not just their eyes -otherwise it would last years. My review for this product states it rinses off 99% completely and 100% when followed up with your normal facial cleanser. For this reason, I would occasionally followup with your normal cleanser to avoid clogged pores. Just like hair products -sometimes you need a clarifying shampoo to remove buildup.

I think this is way too rich to use as your regular cleanser. Best to use their cream based calming cleanser instead.

I wouldn't use just this product in place of a skin care system. Its more of a makeup remover/disolver.

I use a wet washcloth and it works perfectly.

Oil cleansers are generally made for makeup removal. Take The Day Off is also oil based, though not liquidy like most oil products. If you don't wear makeup on a daily basis or none at all, I would recommend to use just a regular face cleanser.

I use this because my face leans toward being dry. I live in a dry climate, I spend a fair amount of time outside, we have hard water/ all things that dry out the skin. For those reasons, I find this cleansing balm to very effective. If my skin was on the oily side and I lived in a humid climate, I wouldn't bother with this product.

i wouldn't recommend using at as a regular facial cleanser, but Clinique does have pretty inexpensive facial cleansers that you can pick up. :)

Yes, it's a perfect cleanser for your skin even if you don't wear makeup. It cleans without stripping the natural oils from your face and softens your skin without making it greasy. I love it!

Yes, I definitely think this could be used as a stand-alone cleanser, especially if you don't have oily skin. When I rinse with warm water, it comes off, taking the makeup or dirt with it, and it leaves the skin silky smooth and soft. If you had oily skin or a tendency to blemishes, I would think you would need to use a toner or wash with soap after using this product. But I don't find that necessary at all. I really like the product, and I've never seen anything else like it, although I have used (and liked) other just regular oil cleansers. Try it, I think you'll find it works great.

I use this product evryday in my bedtime routine even on the day when I don't wear any make up. My skin gets so dry in the winter time. It helps to soften skin before I put my night cream on.

Yes, this is how the product is made. It is a solid balm but in a good way. Run your finger across it and it will melt with the heat from your body.

This product is meant to have a thick hard consistency!! You scrape a small amount off the top with the spatula and rub it between your hands and it turns into a silky oil that you apply to your face than rinse off. It rinses off completely!! You will not feel greasy after rinsing but you do need to follow with your regular cleanser. This product was not meant to be used as a cleanser!! It is to be used as a makup remover so you can go on to the rest of your cleansing process. I love it and I believe you will to!!

It is supposed to be hard, kinda like a solid mass but as you rub your fingers in it, it will emulsify. Definitely different if you're use to an liquid oil. I rub it and get a little at a time and put it on my eyes, then rub it some more and put it on my face.

It is supposed to be hard in the jar, and the warmth from your fingertips melts it into a liquid type consistency. Then you rub it on your face and it thins out more on your face.

Yes that is how it is supposed to be. Just put a little on your fingertips and let it do it's magic, and you also don't have to use a lot :)

The balm arrives in a hard, almost waxy consistency, and then when you rub it onto your fingers it becomes silky, like a real balm.

The product is a balm, so it is meant to be a solid. You should find, however, that it starts to soften when the heat of your fingertips rubs against the product (i.e. when you are removing an amount from the jar). The product liquifies when rubbed gently around the eyes. Gently...that's all you need.

In its natural state, the balm is solid-- it could be somewhat hard the colder the weather is. However, once it warms in your fingers or on your skin, it dissolves slowly, eventually into a more fluid balm.

its opaque and hard, looks a bit like candle wax, so use your finger to scrape off a small amount and apply to your face - as soon as you gently press it against your face the product starts 'melting' into a creamy consistency very quickly and begins to work - it feels so soft and its very effective.

Easily.

Yes! I use waterproof mascara all the time, and use the take it off balm nightly to remove everything. I rub a little onto my face with my fingers (mixed with some warm water) and wipe it all off with a damp face cloth.

Yes it does remove waterproof mascara. It takes a little extra rubbing but it does remove it with the use of a wash cloth. I wear covergirl lashblast waterproof mascara and I usually apply more than one coat and it removes it fully.

Yes, really well! Depending on how much you wear, it helps to put it on, rub it in, and leave your fingers over your lashes for a few seconds, then rub it away.

Yes, this product removes every ounce of waterproof mascara.

Yes, this product takes off all eye makeup including waterproof mascara!! Try it. I believe you will love it as much as I do!!

Easily.... you just have to work in the product gently onto your lashes and it will melt the mascara (or any waterproof eyeliner, eyeshadow, whatever) right off!

Yes!

I use different mascaras for different looks, and this balm takes it off completely with no problem. I just have to massage it into my lashes for 30 seconds or so before wiping or rinsing it off.

I think this product is perfect for every skin type. There aren't any fragrances or dyes in it. This product would be ideal for someone with sensitive skin and definitely would NOT clog your pores. Another plus...leaves your skin super soft.

I have oily/acne prone skin and I also use sunscreen, mineral powder foundation and lots of eye makeup!! Take the Day Off Cleasing Balm removes it all!! This product was not meant to be used as a cleanser, it is a makeup remover, to be followed by your regular cleanser. I not only have oily/acne prone skin but sensitive skin as well. My skin loves this and when I am done using this product and my cleanser my face is clean and soft!! I have had no problem with clogged pores!!

It will remove your waterproof makeup and sunscreen.... you just have to use enough for a very thin layer on your entire face and rub it in for a few seconds. I have acne-prone skin and this product has never caused a flare, but I do use a gentle face wash after using this. It does not sting the eyes (and I have gotten it into my eyes many times.... my eyes are somewhat sensitive from laser eye surgery).

I have oily and large pores as well and this will not clog them. It goes on smooth and rinse completely clean. I always wash afterwards with my face wash for a double cleanse.

I have oily skin that breaks out occasionally, and this product rinses clean away. No residue, and it cleans off the makeup so it actually prevents breakouts for me. Good for all skin types.

All Clinique products are designed for people with sensitive skin in mind. They do not use typical harsh chemicals or fragrances as with other brands. In fact, their line is fragrance free. My face is not highly sensitive, however. The description for the product does state that it will dissolve makeup AND sunscreen. It does rinse cleanly off your skin and there is no need to really work the product for it to be effective. You could always get a sample and test it on your arm to see if it removes your sunscreen to your liking. I don't think you'll be disappointed.

Here's the ingredients: Ethylhexyl Palmitate, Carthamus Tinctorius (safflower) seed oil, Caprylic / Capric Triglyceride, Sorbeth-30, Tetraoleate, Polyethylene, Peg-5, Glyceryl Triisostearate, Water/Aua/Eau-Tocopher-ol, Phenoxyethanol

As with all Clinique products, it is fragrance free. It does contain some oils (vitamin e and safflower, for example), but it rinses off 99% completely and 100% when followed with your regular facial cleanser. It does not leave a residue when followed with your cleanser.

No fragrance.
Lightweight

Ethylhexyl Palmitate, Carthamus Tinctorius (Safflower) Seed Oil, Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Sorbeth-30 Tetraoleate, Polyethylene, Peg-5 Glyceryl Triisostearate, Water, Tocopherol, Phenoxyethanol

No fragrance, Clinique does not use fragrance in their skin products.