Unfortunately, Black Lily is most likely gone forever. I've emailed the Clinique company for a recommendation of a similar color, and they recommend the Almost Lipstick in Black Honey. Those of us who are very familiar with Black Lily know that there IS a difference: Black Honey has more of a brownish tone to it, whereas the Black Lily had more of a pink/red tone. It was your lips, but better.
That being said, I think the new Almost Lipstick color in Chic Honey comes closer to Black Lily if only because of its faint reddish tone, though still, it lacks the opacity of our much missed lippy. Sigh.
answered 3 years, 7 months ago
I checked the Clinique Site and I'm sad to say I didn't run across it. If I knew of a comparable shade, I'd recommend one. You know, they discontinued one of my favorite shades a few years ago, but I just looked and they brought it back... so maybe if you use your Wonder Woman Powers and (and by that I mean, nicely in a non-violent manner) ask them to bring it back, or see if just maybe they have some left overs somewhere. The White Coat Brigade is usually a cool group and very helpful.