This product didn't clump at all in my experience, and I am on my second tube. However this mascara really lengthens your lashes. So if you already have long eyelashes maybe you should instead concentrate on a mascara that will give you volume (which is not this mascara) since this might make your already long lashes look a bit fake or showy.

I think this would be a perfect mascara for you. It doesn't clump, and provides a clean, natural look while still looking like you have mascara on.
And you know Sephora, if it isn't for you, they'll take it back. Try it!

I believe that you will ge tthe effect that you are lookingfor with this mascara; it's def a natural looking mascara w/ one or two sweeps ofthe brush. I, on the other hand, like my eyelashes to pop so I have to run the brush over my eyelashes a few times to get that effect.

I love this mascara...I don't like that spider look on my lashes...I wear it alone during the day and at night, I wear a "cheap" mascara then put the Tarte on as a second coat...gives it a full look without the clumping

Because you like a natural look this might be great for you. I like more of a dramatic look and this left mine natural looking. goodluck!

This is a thick mascara, if your lashes curl naturally, I wouldn't use it. Mine dont, and their thin and I can't use it. Clumps horribly and makes me look worse than Bobo the Clown.

This mascara is only great for people who don't use the twiggy look. If you try to layer the bajeezuz out of it, it will look thick and clumpy and gross.

BUT! SInce you don't use much, You will love it.

no way its amazing. my favorite so far. and the only thing i obsess over is mascara. not a big make up wearer

This is a very natural product - it does not clump and as an added bonus contains many ingredients that boost the health of the lashes themselves.

This mascara creates a very dark dramatic look, if you're looking for a subtle natural look, this probably isn't for you.

It is definitely natural glam. My lashes aren't anything to write home about, but this mascara can go anywhere from subtle with one coat to intense with...well, I can't say I really count, but rest assured one coat with be perfectly natural and lovely!

It does flake! I don't like it. Maybe it wouldn't flake if you used a primer. No stinging or watery eyes though.

I haven't had any flaking at all even when I touch my lashes. No watery eyes either. My mom also uses it and has had no issues.

No it lasts all day and you can add to it before you go out at night for even bigger lashes without it flaking under your eyes.

Nope. It is actually one of the better mascaras I have used. In Dior, I would always get little flakes under my eyes during a stressful day but not with this one. And Dior kinda irritated my eyes too if I slept in it overnight but this one doesn't. The only time I had slight itchiness was when I accidentally applied some of this mascara too far inside my bottom lashes and it irritated my eyes just a bit but after washing it out, it was not a problem.

With my experience no. It has the best wear all day. I workout during my lunch and after work and stays on great. I also have sensitive eyes and it has yet to affect them.

The mascara formula is very stable and doesn't flake. My skin is hypersensitive, so I cannot wear anything irritating like SPF lotions, etc, and this mascara hasn't irritated my eyes at all. However, I will note that when it's humid outside, it does tend to run a bit, so I would definitely use a light waterproof topcoat to ensure all-day wear.

I haven't known it to flake or sting in my experience with it. I think I am on my 3rd or 4th .

Just started wearing it today, but so far no flakes at all! No "raccoon eyes" either. Love it!

I find it does during application and even after. Not a good buy.

I've used this for about a week and have not had any flaking or watering issues.

No I've never had it flake, you can just keep putting on coat after coat. Because of the conditioner it stays soft.

I prefer the Tarte mascara. Both are good but for me, Tarte applies easier and looks nicer.

I prefer it to Buxom as it defines better.

I like Tarte's LCL better than Buxom. I find Buxom dries out quickly and can be clumpy at times. The brush for Tarte is easier to use than the fatter brush from Buxom. I find it easy to get the small lashes in the inside corners.

I wear all of bare minerals makeup except the mascara now. I like this better. I did not like buxom's brush. I like this one because it is very narrow at tip to get the inside lashes. Stays all day, washes off easily with bare minerals cleanser. Has not clumped up once.

Tarte mascara flaked off after a short time. Although Tarte volumized, lengthening & curling were minimal. I am a frequent masara shopper, searching for the Holy Grail of mascaras, and I found that Buxom mascara worked better & stayed on without flaking.

i like it better. it feels better on the eyes. i think its less volumizing but still looks great. i have long lashes. this is good for definition.

Much better formula than buxom. Smoother to apply and add additional layers and doesn't damage your lashes!

So much better than Buxom, I think.

Much better than Buxom. Paraben, sulfate and phthalate-free. It really seems to condition my lashes. Best of all...no clumps. I found Buxom to be the opposite. You won't be disappointed.

Tarte is better, at least for me, more natural and keeps the curl all day.. not only for 5 mins like buxom....

Healthier, I am not sure, but I definitely prefer the performance to Buxom.

i got the regualr and it does not hold a curl

The waterproof definitely does not hold a curl nor does it define the lashes quite as well. That being said, it's still the best mascara out there for those days that you know you'll be shedding a tear.

I really don't think you need waterproof. The regular really stays on and I have really watery eyes. I did not get the waterproof because it is really hard to remove. Try the regular first and you can always bring it back to Sephoria and they will refund your money of you need the waterproof

I'd go with regular unless you're scuba diving. It's pretty tough! I was in a pool with the non waterproof and it was fine

i've tried both and i prefer the regular. the waterproof doesn't seem as moisturizing and smooth to me. the regular lasts long enough to stay on for a night out.

i am not sure which holds a curl better, but i would only get the waterproof if i were going to be in a situations that involved water/getting wet/crying.

This mascara is awful! There is no resistance when the wand is pulled out and it comes out with huge clumps of gummy mascara that gets worse each time you use it! You end up wiping $20 of mascara off onto tissues. It also flakes something awful and makes lashes look very clumpy and not natural at all!

not sure how much help this is, but i have never tried the waterproof, because the regular really doesn't smear much-you have to use makeup remover to get it all the way off as a rule. Good luck! i have been REALLy happy with it since a consultant recommended it to me.

The waterproof mascara is not as great at curling i found. if you want full performance mascara i would go with the regular non waterproof. the waterproof tends to be a bit stickier and isnt as great at creating volume.

I dislike waterproof because it never comes off. I have really bad watery eyes because of allergies and this mascara stays put for at least 13 hours. I even took a nap in it and my eyes still looked great!

I got both the regular and waterproof samples in a free gift and I think the regular is WAY better! The waterproof was really clumpy and ended up not being waterproof at all ! Go for the regular ! And this is by far my fave mascara that I've tried !

Superior to Lancome...which I have used for the past 20 years!

I have used both, they are not similar. I would say the Defencils is more defining for an every-day mascara and Tarte is more "huge" volumninous lashes.

You should try it!! It is fantastic!! I had Lancome at one point and liked it, but it separated too much and didn't give me the volume I wanted. Tarte does!!

Before switching to naturals, I was a huge Lancome fan (for at least 20 years). Definicils is a great mascara, Tarte is just as good with the benefit of being "natural" . Key difference - is that you can layer a little better with definicil and it lenghtens just a bit more, but all in all, Tarte does a really good job.

I've tried both - in fact I've tried them all I think. This one is as defining but much thicker. It's the best.

I prefer Tarte. Lancome takes too long to dry and I found it clumps. Tarte looks more natural (and IS natural) but still gives thickness and length.

I used Lancome definicils from the time I was 16. I'm 38 now, and switched to Tarte last year. I will never go back to Lancome.
Hope that helps!

I like it better because it gives more volume. Not as defining though.

I also was a die-hard defincils user, but then I tried a sample and fell in love. I love it because: it lasts all day, doesnt flake off, makes my lashes longer than any other, and it comes off easily in the shower (I use Cetaphil).

I was devoted to Lancome Defincils for YEARS. Then I developed an allergy to it and was devastated that I couldn't use it anymore. This turned out to be a blessing in disguise because I was forced to find something else that was a more natural, gentler formula. Little did I know that my quest for something new would lead me to something far superior - I think. Given the choice, I would never go back to Lancome now. I love this mascara. It's worth trying it - it's cheaper than Lancome too.

I curl before applying and this mascara does extremely well with curling. Sometimes if i know i will be out a while i curl after applying and all i can say is WOW. If you want to try it out, they have a kit that comes with an eyelash curler and a trial size of this mascara for 15$. :D

Yes, my lashes stay curled all day with this mascara. I use an eyelash curler first before applying the mascara.

It lenghtens so well you might want to use a curler. Once you do though it stays put

No it didn't curl, but its very defining and lengthening

For me, this mascara hold a curl all day. but It rreally depends on the person. You should try the smalle size of this mascara befor buying the full size.

I would use a waterproof mascara if you're looking for your lashes to really hold curl. Try Tarte MultiplEYE Clinically-Proven Lash Enhancing Waterproof Mascara. It actually washes off very easy for being a waterproof mascara, and because it is waterproof it will hold curl better.

It holds curl well when used with a lash curler.

I think it ultimately depends on how the person's eyelashes are. I have extremely straight and stubborn eyelashes. When I applied this product i curld my eyelashes and applied the mascara after. Once it dried my eyelashes started drooping and then I had to curl them multiple times. So if you have very stubborn eyelashes like mine, I don't recommend this product.

I get a slight curl from this but not much... the other features outshine the curl factor...define, volume, etc.

I haven't found a mascara yet that curls well. I always have to recurl after application, but it seems to hold fairly well after the recurl.

No, it does not smudge or run easily after it has had a minute to set.

No

It doesn't smudge or run. You practically have to yell at it to get it off at the end of even a loooong day.

No smudging experienced!

I have never had this mascara smudge or run. Sometimes I forget that I have mascara on and will rub my eyes. Even when I do that, it doesn't smudge, it just turns into a fine powder and can be brushed off of your face and may even come off all on its own.

This mascarra is the Happy Holiday answer for NO SMUGE, and washes off easy, I wish I could send you the money to buy one and just see how happy you'll be with it. I use baby bath soap to wash it off I am just so happy to finally find a mascarra that is healthy, loads on, and no smug, and great all day wear. love sissy

Not unless you're swimming or in a kickboxing class. I have never experienced clumps or flaking and would recommend Lights, Camera Splashes if you want budge/smudge-proof.

I have used this mascara for about 4 months and I have yet for it to run or smudge. Once it dries it is there until you want it off.

I did not find any problems like that and I have been using for a couple of months..

No smudges and no runs. Also, no flakes :)

I'm not Asian but have short straight lashes & have to use an eyelash curler. This mascara adds to the curl & length.

I have Asian lashes too so mine are short and stick down and are not full. I use this mascara with Shu Umera eyelash curler and it works wonderful. I use the curler first to curl the eyelashes and then I put about 4-5 coats for each eye. And I finish it off by curling it again with the eyelash curler. Works great and holds up for the majority of the day. I usually curl it again in the evening if I'm going out so it'll perk back up.

The product information says that it creates 92% curlier lashes. However, this is not a mascara to be used if you would like to create uber thick layers of mascara, it is best used lightly. If you are unsure about this mascara, it is best to find a store near you that sells it and try it out for yourself. Also, there is a waterproof version of this same mascara that may better suit your needs if it is usually waterproof mascaras that work for you.

I use an eyelash curler as a matter of keeping lashes off glass lenses. My lashes stay curled till my face is washed though if that helps

I'm Asian and I have the same, exact problem as you do! I have found that no non-waterproof mascaras keep the curl, at all. I have tried dozens and found that if my curl stays, the mascara is waterproof. The only waterproof mascara that NEVER uncurls my lashes is Waterproof Maybelline Lash Discovery. I tried the non-waterproof version and it totally uncurled my lashes, unlike the waterproof one. So I figured there must be something in some waterproof mascaras that keep from uncurling my lashes. I don't know what it is, though. Wish I did!

I would also like to know if anyone else knows a mascara that doesn't uncurl lashes. I can't seem to find any. I actually liked the sample of this mascara. It did lengthen and volumize my lashes, but I had to recurl my lashes after applying. But when I did, my lashes looked amazing. I want to get the full-size product but noticed there is a waterproof version. I might get both and if I do, I'll let you know how they are.

My lashes will straighten with most mascaras. This is yet another mascara that straightened my lashes.

Nope does not appear to hold curl... just like other mascaras.

Try Cargo Triple Action mascara. That really holds a curl.

This curls and does whatever you want it to do. It's the best.

I have the same problem, trying to find a mascara that will hold the curl. No matter what mascara I've used, I ALWAYS have to recurl after application. This mascara is so-so.

When I work out I tend to get a slight raccoon eye on my lower lid, but this stays on pretty well for moderate exercise. If you are really working and dripping sweat, this will run a lot. Since this is not water proof, I always have to remove it before I get into the pool to do laps; it will run all over your face. I hope this helps!

This product does not fair well under pressure or water. It is not water resistant. For a water resistant formula by Tarte, try Lights, Camera, Splashes mascara.

This is not a waterproof formula but I do find that it holds up with slightly teary eyes or minimal sweat. They do have a waterproof version however I don't really like the way it goes on.

Not waterproof, waterproof mascara is the worst thing you can put on your lashes. Use it at your wedding then throw it out!!!

This holds up alright against tears but if you are sobbing as opposed to just having watery eyes, this will definitely streak down your face

This mascara is not waterproof but does hold up fairly well against tears. While it won't leave mascara marks streaming down your face, if you've been crying, and sort of blot your lashes with a tissue, it will come off a little bit. They have a waterproof version with a super adorable anchor on it, so maybe that would be a good bet. Haven't tried it, but believe me this mascara is TOTALLY worth it!

This product stays put all day, thru running allergy eyes even. It doesn't come off, until I take it off.

I find that no, not very. But if your eyes get wet, they will clump a bit, just don't rub them, and wait for them to dry a bit and try to separate the clumps

GOOD

dont think its waterproof, but ive been to the gym with it on, cried at movies with it on, and was a drunken mess with it on, and the only thing that phased it was an actual shower. even then, it wasnt so bad!

Lights, Camera, Lashes is a great mascara all around. Never clumpy, leaves your lashes with a lot of definition and separation (not that spidery look) and stays on all day without flaking off. It's not a dramatic mascara like Diorshow, but I think of it as an everyday, going-to-the-office mascara. Plus, it leaves your lashes healthier! If you're not convinced, go to your local Sephora and try some on!

I use it on upper and lower lashes and it stays all day.

I am on my second tube and have never had a problem with this mascara running unless I'm crying. I don't sweat much so I can't personally comment on the product in that situation. Tarte does make this product in a waterproof formula as well called "Lights, Camera, Splashes!" I also have never used the waterproof formula as I try to stay away from them unless I'm going to a wedding, funeral, etc.

I would suggest with any mascara that you try to dry/wipe off your lashes of any eyeshadow, lotion, or other product that could have gotten on them while applying the rest of your makeup. Mascara is the last product I apply. I just blink them against a hand towel right before applying my mascara. It may not completely solve the problem, but it does help. ;)

Been wearing this mascara for a month now, almost every day. never had an issue with it ending up under my eyes...

It stays all day for me, until I remove it with a makeup remover at night.

When you're applying the mascara it gets underneath your lashes quite a bit but it doesn't really come off throughout the day. Worth a try!

no smudging not running!! Hands down my favorite mascara. I consider it flawless!!

Never had that problem with this mascara. After my initial application it stays put and it's long-lasting. No smudges or running in sight. P.S. My lashes are fairly long.

Yes, yes, yes! I often have the same issue though not with this product.